Subject: The Best Manager In Sokker

Voting Open (Closes midnight 28th)

Round 2 (Part 1)

Reca Vs Marcodona
Tigermaster Vs Kaisser
Ganzengeile Vs javi77
Lmoran Vs Magnum
Shadow Vs texwit
Denzel Vs SkywalkerPUCP
Julius Vs Forestman
Phil_Fox85 Vs Chilenese
Cometer Vs theunis
icciban Vs Vilpu
Shadowman Vs Sharoni
Neuromancer Vs red
Gaudin Vs Ringhiostarr
Borkos Vs rbazzarela
MacLanghe Vs farilhao
Maqoma Vs Seca
(edited)

No question`s Vilpu is the best

---

Just for the sake of my sanity, can we not have numbers please? It's not always easy to read

I will vote more on tactical basis


Reca Vs Marcodona

I know both are great managers and tacticians, but i consider Reca has a slight advantage in this clash


Tigermaster Vs Kaisser
Looking at the tactics of Kaisser and knowing the tactical skill of Tiger, i would chose Tigermaster

Ganzengeile Vs javi77
Both managers have great teams, with lots of trophies,but Ganzengeile is better at tactics (imho), plus he has more trophies won (highest league).


Lmoran Vs Magnum
For me without doubt Mangum, he managed to create a great team, plus his tactics are also great.


Shadow Vs texwit
Shadow, ofc, i know texwit is also a good manager, but Shadow due to his great performances managed to become a sokker legend, so my vote goes to him.


Denzel Vs SkywalkerPUCP

To be serious i was amazed to see Denzel nominated, even though Skywalker is just superior to him...
Julius Vs Forestman
Uhh, hard to decide, but my vote goes to Forestman, Julius just was in the highest division, but didn't managed to win the league, plus Forestman is better tactically(imho)


Phil_Fox85 Vs Chilenese
Hard draw, both great tacticians, also both have nice teams, but i consider Phil_Fox is slightly better.


Cometer Vs theunis

Hmm, tactically theunis isn't that great, while Cometer has very nice tactics...

icciban Vs Vilpu
Very hard draw. I know that both are just one of the greatest tacticians of sokker, Vilpu had great results with NZ, Eesti and a great team. Icciban as i know had great results with Russia U21, has a bit better team , so even if icciban is a friend of mine, my vote goes to Vilpu.


Shadowman Vs Sharoni
Both have great teams, even if the Israel championship looks a bit easier than the dutch one, he has great performances with a great team. Plus the work done by Sharoni with the Latvian NT is awesome, he made from a weak NT a team that entered in pot 3 even if there are better teams that are lower in the rank. So my vote goes to him



Neuromancer Vs red

Both nice dudes and managers, but i see Neuromances a better tactician.


Gaudin Vs Ringhiostarr

Gaudin this season won the Highest League of Poland. Ringhio is also a good manager, has a good team, but imho winning the polish league is harder so Gaudin gets my vote

Borkos Vs rbazzarela

Borkos has a great opponent, but what he did as NT coach gives hime in my view an advantage


MacLanghe Vs farilhao

Farilhao has a good team, but tactically he is like an average user, while Langhe is a great tactician.



Maqoma Vs Seca

Uuuu, nice clash, don't know how to comment.. My vote goes to Maqoma

Reca Vs Marcodona 2
Tigermaster Vs Kaisser 2
Ganzengeile Vs javi77 1
Lmoran Vs Magnum 2
Shadow Vs texwit 1
Denzel Vs SkywalkerPUCP 2
Julius Vs Forestman 1
Phil_Fox85 Vs Chilenese 1
Cometer Vs theunis 1
icciban Vs Vilpu 2
Shadowman Vs Sharoni 2
Neuromancer Vs red 2
Gaudin Vs Ringhiostarr 1
Borkos Vs rbazzarela 2
MacLanghe Vs farilhao 1
Maqoma Vs Seca 1

Reca Vs Marcodona 2
Tigermaster Vs Kaisser 1
Ganzengeile Vs javi77 1
Lmoran Vs Magnum 1
Shadow Vs texwit 1
Denzel Vs SkywalkerPUCP 1
Julius Vs Forestman 1
Phil_Fox85 Vs Chilenese 1
Cometer Vs theunis 1
icciban Vs Vilpu 2
Shadowman Vs Sharoni 1
Neuromancer Vs red 2
Gaudin Vs Ringhiostarr 1
Borkos Vs rbazzarela 1
MacLanghe Vs farilhao 1
Maqoma Vs Seca 2

I'm gutted to be facing you too, doesn't seem fair.

We should have been seeded ;-)

Reca Vs Marcodona
These 2 are very even though I'd say Marcodona has more league titles while Reca is evidently more of a cup specialist. Tactically I think Reca is slightly better

Tigermaster Vs Kaisser

Neither have had as much success as I expected but Tigermaster has won the title and that's enough.

Ganzengeile Vs javi77
A very unfortunate match as I'm a big fan of both but I've always believed that Geg could pull off a win against anyone.

Lmoran Vs Magnum

Magnum is easily one of the best 10 managers in this game and has had continued success in what to me, is probably one of the tactically best leagues in the game.

Shadow Vs texwit
Shadow is legendary and in this case, comparison is quite easy.

Denzel Vs SkywalkerPUCP
I'm not overly familiar with Denzel and while he seems fairly solid has yet to reach the top league, Skywalker dominated Peru for some time.

Julius Vs Forestman
Because Julius never managed to win the league despite being here from the beginning.

Phil_Fox85 Vs Chilenese
Impossible choice. I think because Phil isn't in the top league and isn't looking like promoting this season I'm going Mexican.

Cometer Vs theunis
Cometer wins on tactics.

icciban Vs Vilpu
icciban is a great manager but has never won the Italian title. Vilpu is quite possibly the best manager in this game.

Shadowman Vs Sharoni
Old guard vs the new guard. Shadowman was for a long time the only manager who could compete with Polish teams and dominated the Dutch league. Sharoni owns the Israeli league and has done for some time. I'll go with the slightly more difficult league.

Neuromancer Vs red
Very similar but Neuro is capable of tactical brilliance as he has shown consistently with the NT this season.

Gaudin Vs Ringhiostarr

You have to take the soon to be Polish champion over a relative newbie

Borkos Vs rbazzarela
I'm going with a surprise choice here. Borkos is a legendary trainer and is well known but hasn't had any club success, neither has Rbazz but the speed at which he's progressed suggest he's likely to dominate Brazil for seasons to come.

MacLanghe Vs farilhao
Because of the league wins

Maqoma Vs Seca
Seca doesn't get the credit he deserves because of the league he's in but his national results could be very impressive.
(edited)

Phil is going to be monstrous soon, some of his trainees in a couple of years...

I'm going with a surprise choice here. Borkos is a legendary trainer and is well known but hasn't had any club success, neither has Rbazz but the speed at which he's progressed suggest he's likely to dominate Brazil for seasons to come.

Actually, I had a pretty decent progress speed as well. I was one of the youngest users to join Ekstraklasa :) It hurt my team though, because of always playing for the win I ended up with a great team, but not good enough to achieve anything more than one of the low places in the Ekstraklasa. If I've chosen a more balanced approach to 'going up', then I would've bigger chance to win something in Poland.
Still, I consider it as an achievement...together with some of my NT work and making Deroo the first 3 s-divine striker :)

Still, rbazzarella has a great team and progress rate, so I wouldn't really say that chosing him is a weird choice and I have a feeling that it will end as a close one.

In order to give a fair vote I will this time give a more in-depth look at all the participants, so I'll post my votes later :)
(edited)

Marek and Ultra, after NIN wrote:

Nin to PaFPiFPuF
Just for the sake of my sanity, can we not have numbers please? It's not always easy to read


you both post with numbers, yeah, , bravo!

I do expect to win my league, and have a decent chance of promotion back to the premiership this season.

However, to defend my current league placing, I sold my entire squad a few seasons ago after winning the premiership twice in a row. With the money I bought really young trainees. Some of these trainees are now getting to be decent players, but are all still really young and do hold me back as you can only be 'so' good at a young age. Still, even with this young team, I managed to win the cup this season.

The money I raised from selling my squad is still pretty much in the bank (over 50M euro's), and I don't plan to spend it, I prefer the challenge of getting back to the top without spending the money. So I have pretty much started again as I only re-invested a small proportion of the money I raised initially selling off my squad.

Reca Vs Marcodona 2
Tigermaster Vs Kaisser ?
Ganzengeile Vs javi77 1
Lmoran Vs Magnum 2
Shadow Vs texwit 1
Denzel Vs SkywalkerPUCP 2
Julius Vs Forestman 1
Phil_Fox85 Vs Chilenese 1
Cometer Vs theunis 1
icciban Vs Vilpu 111111 :)
Shadowman Vs Sharoni 2
Neuromancer Vs red 1
Gaudin Vs Ringhiostarr 1
Borkos Vs rbazzarela 1
MacLanghe Vs farilhao 1
Maqoma Vs Seca 1

We should have been seeded ;-)

Why, you don't win trophies?

Yeah you're doing the same thing I have been doing for the last couple of seasons. As I said it was an impossible choice in the end so I went with who looked to be doing the best, you're quite welcome to use my own methodology to bury me against Uamini :D