Subject: Fake Talent Warning

True, but the screen still looks like handpainted fake:)

Why would he fake such a bad talent? ;)

But seriously, i am not convinced it is fake. It surely can be, but i do not see it as a clear fake. I think it is possible that it is a bad risized picture.
(edited)

yes, but the last 'pop' line still worries me :)

Author accepts explanations and appologises about accusations
(edited)

huh?

I don't get it...
maybe he didn't train it...

I know papuc a bit, I don't think he may fake a screen or something...

to be honest, I can't believe that papuc should be a cheater. do you have a better proof (sv or sth like that)? how good was your youth coach?

Author accepts explanations
(edited)

"How would you explain very slow progress from Solid to Very Good? And then fast development from Very Good to current skill"

random training. maybe he didn't train pm for a long time.

if you have sv screens post them and you can make a lot clearer.

your graph is youth school graph, so it doesn't count in training...
ok, it's nice to have a nice youth school talent, bla bla, but senior training is senior training...

so you say he poped from solid to very good in 8 weeks?
maybe he didn't train him... he trained other skills also...

his current graph seems ok, and, if you ask me, I believe him...

My youth coach is Incredible.

And yes. I do have SV. Here is the picture

I think I found the problem...

look at his screen, look at the date.
the screen is since 8th of July, not from today...

so, you thought that he stood 8 weeks with solid pm, because of this delay, exactly 8 weeks (even more, 11-12) since the graph was made til today...
(edited)

of course papucs grapg shows the first weeks of training, just look at the (german) skills

please be more careful when accusing other managers of cheating... 5 weeks with 13er coach is not that bad and papucs screen fits to that talent.

don't tell me :P
(edited)

---

I'm sure it's july

and the players skills are

8-5
7-11
7-4

much worse than today

I don't blame you for what you said, the hidden talent and the fear of talent liars is a part of this game. But I really can't imagine that papuc fakes a screen, and the facts I can see here don't look suspicious to me.

Author accepts explanations
(edited)