Subject: much injuries and red cards

Do you think that there is too much injuries and red cards in this game?
Yes. 37% (146)
No. 28% (108)
No! Actually, it should be more! 9% (35)
Yes! Sometimes I want to leave the game because of that. 26% (103)


Until now the most of the percent..believes that is a problem and they destroy..evere good opinion about injuries.26%+37%=63%.So there is a problem and it is big..

No! Actually, it should be more! 9% (35)

Please ones who voted this,let us get to know you a little? thanks :D

More injuries and red cards?You are crazy!Then we will speak about a hospital manager game.;)

There are 2,5 more red cards per match than in RL

This is bullshit!


I think it's annoying how you (Serbs, Croatians, Greeks,..) all treat other people in this topic. If someone has a different opinion about things, than they are spammers and they should shut up because they don't know what they are talking about.

I, personally, think that there's not much wrong with the number of injuries and the number of red cards, but I can understand that some people have a very unlucky streak. The problem, however, is that you always compare things with real life. Let me do some comparisions for you.

In real life, there are players who are out for a whole season due to injuries.
In real life, players get injured on training.
In real life, suspensions can take multiple weeks.
In real life, if you make a fault as last man in your defence, you'll get a straight red card.

Would you like all of that be implemented too? Sokker is a game and it has it's own set of rules. Each time you think it should be more like real life, you should consider the bad sides of real life too. Sometimes Sokker can be a b*tch, but I think, all in all, that the game is well-balanced.

All this is true!
But Sokker matches lose the match in the first 5 minutes because the attacker make red card.
it is stupid and needs to change.

In real life also..there are more than 15 players in every game..

This is bullshit!

I have proof. Here they are.

Sokker 160 matches data:
1.HNL Sezona 21
Sezona 20 3.liga.03
Sezona 21 3.liga.03
These are averages. If you change cell B12 to number 1, you will get total red cards. Number of games is 14x4=56 or 12x4=48 when one club played only default matches whole season.

Average red cards per match in 160 matches = 0,4 (highest level division = 0,46)

RL 4000+ Bundesliga and Premiership matches:
Article
Based on this data I also made a very useful Excel.Excel.

Real life red card average = 0,18.

You either make a better research or stfu.
(edited)

+1

I think it's annoying how you (Serbs, Croatians, Greeks,..) all treat other people in this topic. If someone has a different opinion about things, than they are spammers and they should shut up because they don't know what they are talking about.


I like your sense of humor :D

if we put everything in some sort of table nothing would make sense.
i agree with you except for this statement about Croats,Serbs and Greeks :)

I think Tevez is actually the most influence on so many injuries in the game :)
i would like to know how would people react on such things in game ant thats obviously noraml in rl..
pls dont make story out of this it's just for example

we don't have enough influence DURING the match to react

Tell me how do you want to change this?

There are 2,5 more red cards per match than in RL and they happen at any minute equally. I don't have data for injuries but my feeling is the same as for cards. They are also too frequent during the matches.

And who's fold is this, the ME? :P

I did not get the answer yet? waiting for yours response

What was the question?

Some of the matches of managers to whom I explained Sokker as mentor, the results of injuries and cards are AMAZING (???):
Fire Boys. - Zware jongens (no injury and no cards)
VV Dokkum - divo f2 (no injury and 1 yellow card)
TheDutchBulls - FC Zomaar (1 injury and no cards, I have to say he is using my advises but not one of my tactics)

And some matches of managers I know of who are using a tactic I showed them:
VVT - Red Cougars (no injury and no cards)
Aiolis - DIKEFALOS AETOS (no injury and 1 yellow card)
De denkers - FC Tacru (1 injury, 1 yellow and 1 red card)
ARMENIAN LEGION - Mhersheva (1 injury, 1 yellow and 1 red card, but yellow and red card for a DEF that was to weak for the opponent)
The Pixies - Cardiff University FC (no injury and 1 yellow card)

So 3 injuries, 5 yellow and 2 red cards in 8 matches. That's not at all shocking if you ask me! And doesn't even come close to the data Kobra 79 is showing us.

The opponents (some experienced, new or bot) often did get more injuries and cards ... a coincidence?

I just saw your post, and games you gave us and....


(edited)

Advantage of high rate of red cards in sokker

- more random (teams with better marks can't be sure they will win only cause they have 5 points batter mark)
- teams who have more players on bench have benefits (closer to RL)
- teams who make more CO have more chance to make adjustments to red card

Disadvantage of high rate of red cards in sokker

- some matches isn't nice to watch
- it is 3 times more than in RL
- sometimes managers can broke they mouse or even screen when they get early red card

there is always advantages and disadvantages of everything and in this case I would say it is even, so they can make some changes, but also, they don't have to do it....only they can make change to make more red cards at the end of game, but not average numbers of red cards