Subject: New match engine discussion

is that if you were an ordinary User, you have the same opinion?
(edited)

Yes ofcourse :) I have tried out many tactics this season with friendly matches and junior matches and did many tactic swaps to see what effect the tactic swap would have. And I noticed when I do a tactic swap during matches it can completely turn around the match result. So this is prove enough tactics still have a big impact on match results. And I think this is also the best way to learn the ME and what effect tactics and skills of players on each position have on match results.

(edited)

Yes ofcourse :)


because then who is always defending the current engine, in most cases, people are connected to the staff?

hardly see ordinary people, which is not part of the staff, agreeing with the current engine.
(edited)

Well... Imo the engine is fair at the moment.... I assume there were some good adjustments after the first update. In 9 of the ten cases the strongest team will win.

Still, there is a lot of random...

one week your team can play like gods, the next with same tactic they look like newbies...

True

one week your team can play like gods, the next with same tactic they look like newbies...


exactly :D

I don't know why that is. Maybe because these managers spend more time on Sokker trying to understand how it all works, or maybe because these managers don't like it anymore that complaining managers (in this case the ones who don't really understand the ME and claiming all is random) to often were the ones responsible for the negative mood on the forums.

On the other hand, there are also enough managers defending the good things of Sokker but have nothing to do with staff at all.
(edited)

If a do remember, ther was a bug in arcade games and one day teams played 2 matches with each other with same tactic, same form etc... And result was different)
Sorry don't remember the result and where it was posted...
It's only for info use)
(edited)

that bug already fixed.

yea it was something like 2-2 and 5-1 :) it was weird. it was also about the same when 2 guys agreed to play few matches with same everything and results were different also.

we all know this engine sucks but come on how many time you need to make a good one. Look at Football manager series. Their engine is the most realistic but i played many many seasons and still find it awful.

it was my game :P

one
two

the result was different, but in general it was quite similar...except for the finishing...

Ofcourse the result is different, not one single match will be exactly the same, although the stronger team will win most of the times, if the stronger team is using a good tactic ofcourse.

Just an example: if players from the stronger team win an average of 80% of all actions during the whole 90 minutes, the stronger team will win absolutely most of the matches. But this also means the weaker team will win actions, and if these are a lot of decisive actions which all leads to goals then the weaker team can beat ones in a while this stronger team. But in most matches the weaker team won't be that lucky to win all these decisive actions and therefore they won't beat the stronger team that often.

that bug already fixed.
bug of different result?)))

In moments and statistic yes, but in result 1-5 and 2-2 it's not quite similar)