Subpage under development, new version coming soon!
Subject: »Do you like the new ME?
That's actually a good question :P Something should be changed, or the text is wrong or his idea of making it more realistic doesn't corresponds with this text :/
I proposed to change the text very long time ago, practically all the users (reading the topic) agreed...but nothing happened.
Talking about the engine, some of my conclusions are confirmed.....I had an awful match in the last round, that kind of match which send the people to quit the game.
I outline that is not about the score and defeat but about the manner it happened.
First of all, my question is: what is to take in consideration, the match report or the visual representation ?? because they often are not giving the same information.
So let me start with the minute 8 : the opponent goalkeeper kick off the ball until the line of my defenders, where the 19 years old Delgado Andres striker, 1,68 m and 71 kilos (a little chubby), form 12/tactical discipline 5, head the ball winning the challenge with the 30 years old Theodor defender, 1,73 m and 72 kilos, form 16/td 13. The defender has excellent playmaking and speed 13, as well as the defending skill 13.....no way that the young striker to have better speed, or playmaking, or technique which could win the defender's defending skill as I could see from his value, not even 40% of the defender's value....in case these skills matter.
So I can see how wide is the engine's random.
In the reality never could happen in the similar situation of above, when the defender has all the time to do marking to the striker.....at the worst, he could foul but never to let the striker to launch one of his mates with a header.
Okay, I pass over, let's say it could happen.....but the ball goes to the penalty box where Muntean defender reaches it......and what is he doing ? he doesn't kick it away but want's to take it over, and he practically leave the ball to the striker who scores easily.
Okay, let's say that sometimes shit happens.....but right in the next action (up to the match report):
"10 minute.
Kacvínar plays the ball through. Kelbassa attempts to pass. Delgado Andrés just manages to reach the ball first. Delgado Andrés shoots. Turtă desperately tries to grasp hold of the ball.
GOOOAAAAAAL!!!
Go Givers - gloria rogova 1:2"
If you look at the visual representation, you'll see something else : Kelbassa opponent midfielder gives a pass, Delgado Andres not even follows the ball but goes right toward the penalty box, Zakonieczny defender reaches the ball not being disturbed of any opponent....and he's doing a lunge and passes the ball back to the penalty box, exactly in the way of the striker who scores easily by the goalkeeper Turta who hopelessly try to save the situation.
You have to be mental deficient to do as the defender has done !! or maybe he was fixing the match without the manager knowledge :) .....and nothing about his blunder in the match report !?!
In the next action, on the match report:
"12 minute.
Kelbassa centers. Theodor wins the ball from behind. Delgado Andrés just manages to reach the ball first. Delgado Andrés has a fantastic effort at goal. Turtă hopelessly throws himself behind the ball.
What a tremendous chance!"
Just look on the visual what means "Theodor wins the ball from behind" !! He is doing a scissors and kicks the ball not toward the opponent half or aside...but backward !? exactly in the way of the striker for to go and score !!
Okay, now I'm sure that few of my players fixed the match !! otherwise it's unexplainable, moreover because comes:
"24 minute.
Theodor cleverly intercepts the pass. Kopciński approaches the ball. Kopciński lobs the ball high into the air. Herzig rises up and heads the ball. Turtă desperately tries to grasp hold of the ball.
GOOOAAAAAAL!!!
Go Givers - gloria rogova 1:3"
The match report is lying again as "Theodor cleverly intercepts the pass" means Theodor defender does another scissors and kicks the ball backward (how can you do that at the middle of the field and to kick the ball backward ??!....you do it exactly reversely !!!), and launch the opponent's side midfielder on the wing, who will cross the ball for a scoring header.
So here is my second conclusion : if you play against a better/sensible more valuable team, the engine might make your defenders to do terrible blunders mainly when you play high defense. Sometimes you're hit by a "bad" random, and your players behave like they are mental, or like they're doing match fixing. The engine doesn't make the opponent's players more inteligent but makes your players stupid.
This engine is doing terrible things sometimes.
Here is a visual record on youtube: http://youtu.be/VofmB0bseUo
(edited)
(edited)
I proposed to change the text very long time ago, practically all the users (reading the topic) agreed...but nothing happened.
Talking about the engine, some of my conclusions are confirmed.....I had an awful match in the last round, that kind of match which send the people to quit the game.
I outline that is not about the score and defeat but about the manner it happened.
First of all, my question is: what is to take in consideration, the match report or the visual representation ?? because they often are not giving the same information.
So let me start with the minute 8 : the opponent goalkeeper kick off the ball until the line of my defenders, where the 19 years old Delgado Andres striker, 1,68 m and 71 kilos (a little chubby), form 12/tactical discipline 5, head the ball winning the challenge with the 30 years old Theodor defender, 1,73 m and 72 kilos, form 16/td 13. The defender has excellent playmaking and speed 13, as well as the defending skill 13.....no way that the young striker to have better speed, or playmaking, or technique which could win the defender's defending skill as I could see from his value, not even 40% of the defender's value....in case these skills matter.
So I can see how wide is the engine's random.
In the reality never could happen in the similar situation of above, when the defender has all the time to do marking to the striker.....at the worst, he could foul but never to let the striker to launch one of his mates with a header.
Okay, I pass over, let's say it could happen.....but the ball goes to the penalty box where Muntean defender reaches it......and what is he doing ? he doesn't kick it away but want's to take it over, and he practically leave the ball to the striker who scores easily.
Okay, let's say that sometimes shit happens.....but right in the next action (up to the match report):
"10 minute.
Kacvínar plays the ball through. Kelbassa attempts to pass. Delgado Andrés just manages to reach the ball first. Delgado Andrés shoots. Turtă desperately tries to grasp hold of the ball.
GOOOAAAAAAL!!!
Go Givers - gloria rogova 1:2"
If you look at the visual representation, you'll see something else : Kelbassa opponent midfielder gives a pass, Delgado Andres not even follows the ball but goes right toward the penalty box, Zakonieczny defender reaches the ball not being disturbed of any opponent....and he's doing a lunge and passes the ball back to the penalty box, exactly in the way of the striker who scores easily by the goalkeeper Turta who hopelessly try to save the situation.
You have to be mental deficient to do as the defender has done !! or maybe he was fixing the match without the manager knowledge :) .....and nothing about his blunder in the match report !?!
In the next action, on the match report:
"12 minute.
Kelbassa centers. Theodor wins the ball from behind. Delgado Andrés just manages to reach the ball first. Delgado Andrés has a fantastic effort at goal. Turtă hopelessly throws himself behind the ball.
What a tremendous chance!"
Just look on the visual what means "Theodor wins the ball from behind" !! He is doing a scissors and kicks the ball not toward the opponent half or aside...but backward !? exactly in the way of the striker for to go and score !!
Okay, now I'm sure that few of my players fixed the match !! otherwise it's unexplainable, moreover because comes:
"24 minute.
Theodor cleverly intercepts the pass. Kopciński approaches the ball. Kopciński lobs the ball high into the air. Herzig rises up and heads the ball. Turtă desperately tries to grasp hold of the ball.
GOOOAAAAAAL!!!
Go Givers - gloria rogova 1:3"
The match report is lying again as "Theodor cleverly intercepts the pass" means Theodor defender does another scissors and kicks the ball backward (how can you do that at the middle of the field and to kick the ball backward ??!....you do it exactly reversely !!!), and launch the opponent's side midfielder on the wing, who will cross the ball for a scoring header.
So here is my second conclusion : if you play against a better/sensible more valuable team, the engine might make your defenders to do terrible blunders mainly when you play high defense. Sometimes you're hit by a "bad" random, and your players behave like they are mental, or like they're doing match fixing. The engine doesn't make the opponent's players more inteligent but makes your players stupid.
This engine is doing terrible things sometimes.
Here is a visual record on youtube: http://youtu.be/VofmB0bseUo
(edited)
(edited)
Watch the video. Worths more than a thousand words :)
just wondering, if Anaconda decided to stop playing sokker.. then why is he banned?
No need to read it all....just watch the video, the first 25 minutes if you have plus, and after that you can read information (as much as you need) from my post for to have the entire picture.
.....at least to see how I conceded the second goal, it's a masterpiece.
.....at least to see how I conceded the second goal, it's a masterpiece.
it was only joke, I don't have any problems with reading ;D
yes, this is boring to always say the same thing. and unfortunatly, some people are tired and left the game. we do not want to death of sokker.
see the last French u21 match vs Israêl, the french wingers done a lot of center and nothing go to a striker, 1 or 2 goals scored should have been normal if the ME was realistic.
see the last French u21 match vs Israêl, the french wingers done a lot of center and nothing go to a striker, 1 or 2 goals scored should have been normal if the ME was realistic.
According to the stats you dominated the match and won by 3 goals, so, where is the problem? :)
jogo Tactics Atceva!2
43% Possession 57%
72%Play in the half 28%
0 Shots 22
yea sure... its okei, only 3-0
(edited)
43% Possession 57%
72%Play in the half 28%
0 Shots 22
yea sure... its okei, only 3-0
(edited)
I am leaving the game cause of the new ME...so I dont like it !
This is not football manager guys...This is pinball manager and the team with the best GK and best ATT wins..or something like that
This season was rediculus for me and my team.I have dedicated so many time the past years for sokker for what?To have now a ME where a team wins and loses for no reason at all.
I am very dissapointed after 3 years playing,but thats the situation...
If one day the game is great again,we ll meet again !
This is not football manager guys...This is pinball manager and the team with the best GK and best ATT wins..or something like that
This season was rediculus for me and my team.I have dedicated so many time the past years for sokker for what?To have now a ME where a team wins and loses for no reason at all.
I am very dissapointed after 3 years playing,but thats the situation...
If one day the game is great again,we ll meet again !
yes, my defs always choose a long pass instead of shot pass to the free mid too...
I like the new ME. Of course it's not perfect yet, but the devs are on the right way. The old ME was so boring and unrealistic.
No, it is boring and irrealistic, do it back! 56% (354)
Yes, because of more realistic results. 20% (124)
Yes, i write in forum why. 3% (17)
No, i write in forum why do it back! 4% (28)
Im just interested in the result. 17% (109)
Szavazatok száma: 632
:)
number of users: 47894
we will see which way they are!