Subject: Difference between 2 magical youth trainers

I was wondering if the first trainer will train junior school players better than the second trainer. The first trainer has better skills however both are magical trainers. What do you think? Why?

Elvio Solíz, edad: 65

salario: 559 500 Bs
club: Akatsuki, país: Bolivia,
mágico [15] entrenador

Efectividad de entrenamiento:
mágica [15] en condición sobrenatural [16] en portería
mágica [15] en rapidez sobrenatural [16] en defensa
sobrenatural [16] en técnica mágica [15] en creación
sobrenatural [16] en pases sobrenatural [16] en anotación

Casimiro Ramos, edad: 63

salario: 403 750 Bs
club: Akatsuki, país: Bolivia,
mágico [15] entrenador

Efectividad de entrenamiento:
sobrenatural [16] en condición brillante [14] en portería
sobrenatural [16] en rapidez sobrenatural [16] en defensa
brillante [14] en técnica increíble [13] en creación
destacada [12] en pases sobrenatural [16] en anotación
(edited)

trainer 1: 125 points = 15.625
trainer 2: 117 pionts = 14.625

I would say it can't be both 15... but it doesn't realy matter. I believe, can't prove it, but it would be logical compared to players, that the first is better.

Define youth players first. If we're talking about junior team, it doesnt matter. If we're talking about young trainees, first is better imho.

Yep, without the right definition what the ts means by youth players, it is impossible to answer this poll correctly.
(edited)

Yes, you should specify what are you referring to, in Sokker terms.

If you mean what coach is better for use as 'Junior coach' (to train the players in the Junior school), both are equivalent (magical coach -the individual skills don't matter-). In fact, the second would be preferable, as he has a lower salary.

If you mean what coach is better for young regular players (not in school), the first is better overall (more higer skills, so better training directly in them, and more residual training in the others as well). Unless you are commited to train Pace/Stamina and disregard the possible advantages in the others, of course.

Do you have any prove for that 14.6 is the same as 15.4? I realy do not see the logic of that. On what other place in sokker are number rounded (in game)?

A player with 16.0 pace is slower then a player with 16.9 pace. It is shown as 'unearthly', but it can play as almost divine.
The general skill of a coach is not a single thing, it is the average of the skills, so why on eath would it be rounded after that? At least it doesn't makes sense to me, so i would like to see evidence or a logical reason or something to stand that position.
(edited)

+1.... i also believe there are subskills in general coach appraisal

Do you have any prove that decimals count and have any influence?

Read my posts and you see I don't claim to know. I say it would be logical compared to the rest of how this game works. Nothing more, nothing less. I do not see such words in your posts. So I ask for proof or, because I think no-one can give that right now, for a logical explanation why it would work that way.

Sorry about that, I will edit the topic, I meant junior school trainer.

of course this is always going to be a question.
and its almost impossible to prove decimal has effect. (i'm sure with lots of data and statistical analysis you could add evidence to theory - not even prove it) its very hard to show difference between magical and unearthly youth coach. especially now. how hard would it be show difference for just a small factor difference

before youth update It was clear that there is subskill of each individual skill even for trainers.
I remember people posted two coaches who had 2x magical and rest unearthly skills. one coach was magical the other was unearthly. so same skills and different general level. why? -> subskill of individual skills.
but then why are wages always the same for 8x unearthly coaches? I dont know. maybe unearthly = "supermagical" same as superdivine is to divine. its just max magical skill.

otherwise maybe your coach who has unearthly skill in what you train isnt best possible coach ;)
i thought this for a while too
(edited)

Your commetary is by far the best input I could have. I think I shoud gather data of unearthly coaches and check how it works. Thanks kenyard

Looks like unearthly coaches with 8x unearthly skills are not the same either so there must be a subskill on them.

My guess is that there is some kind of rounding here when calculating Unearthly coaches. Anyways I will put the results and open another topic so I can see if data can be collected.

Ikars Knope, age: 42
wage: 59 975 €
club: Football Warriors, country: Latvija
unearthly coach
Training effectiveness:
unearthly of stamina unearthly of keeper
unearthly of pace unearthly of defender
unearthly of technique unearthly of playmaker
unearthly of passing unearthly of striker

Gust Kelders, leeftijd: 50
salaris: 60 075 €
club: VVG Alveringem, land: België
buitenaards coach

buitenaards op conditie buitenaards op keepen
buitenaards op snelheid buitenaards op verdedigen
buitenaards op techniek buitenaards op spelinzicht
buitenaards op passen buitenaards op scoren

Isaac Lyons, age: 48
wage: 59 850 $
club: Nanook of the North, country: USA
unearthly coach
Training effectiveness:
unearthly of stamina unearthly of keeper
unearthly of pace unearthly of defender
unearthly of technique unearthly of playmaker
unearthly of passing unearthly of striker

Cristian Bonotto, age: 49
wage: 60 100 €
unearthly coach
Training effectiveness:
unearthly of stamina unearthly of keeper
unearthly of pace unearthly of defender
unearthly of technique unearthly of playmaker
unearthly of passing unearthly of striker

Ivo Kotlár, age: 58
wage: 601 000 Bs
club: !! SK8 or DIE !!, country: Česká republika
unearthly coach Training
effectiveness:
unearthly of stamina unearthly of keeper
unearthly of pace unearthly of defender
unearthly of technique unearthly of playmaker
unearthly of passing unearthly of striker

didnt know that. thought they all were fixed wages before this oO

i know max wage was 60,100 or 60,300 i think the bigger one.

I guess we can safely assume subskill is involved so. especially in new coaches.