Subject: Bargain / Robbed topic 2.0

5.3m... how much can i trust on this graph? Talent should be good right?

Oğuz Karaçaylı, age: 17
club: FROM, country: Türkiye
value : 119 500 u$s
wage: 1 625 u$s
very good [9] form
tragic [0] tactical discipline
height: 172 cm, weight: 74.2 kg, BMI: 25.08

hopeless [1] stamina tragic [0] keeper
good [7] pace unsatisfactory [2] defender
unsatisfactory [2] technique excellent [10] playmaker
excellent [10] passing average [5] striker

> Youth Talent Calculator
(edited)

it is funny how player was sold with talent screen 3.3, yet after you bought him you suddently pull out of nowhere screen with talent 3.02 :D fck cheaters

well... 3,3 is what Sokker asistente says... i think (not sure) mikoos tool is more accurate but maybe i am wrong, dont know why you are angry about it xD

"fck cheaters"

cheater??
i am not even gonna answer that one...

---

mikoos tool

It's not mine, Geston wrote it

3,3 is what Sokker asistente says

Do you have that SA screenshot? I think it should show the same talent because (as far as I know) both tools just show talent calculated with a simple linear regression, but maybe SA does something different in this case

SkTables gives him a 3.1 talent (3.5 minimum) with 80% certainty.

Ok I see him on sktables https://www.sktables.org/talent/ID/30871656

So BoydStevens copied the numbers badly, that would be the correct chart in Geston's tool:

OMG MY BAD hahaha, i indeed put the numbers wrong... but anyways.... is that 3.30 reliable?
(edited)

No, you can't have a fully accurate talent estimation with such chart. For example change that starting "5" to a more likely "6" and it goes to 3.50.

For example change that starting "5" to a more likely "6" and it goes to 3.50.

well also that 11 exit level is more likely 12 so... i think is the same there but in a good way right?

Yes, it would work the same but in a good way if skills are better then expected SS from this tool. But he could have started easily as 7 aswell.

According to sktables max starting level is 6 (talent 3.9 max); the most unfavorable probabilities are eliminated.
Sumskills also match the prediction (close to 12) 3.4 or close to, seems fine.

Talent: 3.4 ~ uncertain

Sorry, but your tool is not great in this regard (junior talent estimation with probability)…
Of course this junior could have started as a good junior in youth school
(edited)

Of course :-)

Well lets see... hope it is close to 3.3, thanks guys for the info