Subject: »Bargain or Robbed

other time?? ^^

B for me!:)

Look at this player:

Up for sale for: 150 000 £
highest bid: 159 600 £ [Świętokrzyskie United]
End of bidding: 07.05.2008 22:47


Cataldo Nardulli, age: 18
value: 38 850 £, wage: 630 £
club: show boys, country: Italia
tragic form, hopeless tactical discipline

adequate stamina, tragic keeper
average pace, formidable defender
unsatisfactory technique, weak playmaker
poor passing, weak striker

Not my player. But your opinions, is it bargain or robbed?

Pretty hard to say without talent. But I'd say slightly bargain if normally talented.

unsatisfactory tech :S expensive, maybe 50 pounds

Have you seen his defender skill and better yet, his age. If talented then he will improve.

bargain, look at his age

you really, really over-estimate the importance of technique..

And even if it would have been that important, taking it to adequate would take 6 weeks with a decent talent..

that 19yo Def was a great def, a lot better then yours

or you low-estimate ^^

18 yo mate :D

150k for him is a bargain but to be honest, you'd be better off finding a much better trainee. He'll never ammount to be anything other than ok, not only because of his technique but because he's completely lacking passing and playmaking and his pace needs work.
I'd also remind some people that he's an old 18 year old.

If he was like this:

age:20


weak stamina, tragic keeper
poor pace, average defender
hopeless technique, incredible playmaker
adequate passing, weak striker


bought for 57k

bargain or robbed?

Robbed because he's crap. Even with the new engine, Playmaking is still the most useless skill.

18 yo mate :D

sorry mate, i meant the player before that..

robbed 57 eur

not sure, he is gonna need a lot of training to make profit... Besides, what's the point of his high playmaking? :s
(edited)