Subject: Bargain or Robbed? You decide

I had him planned for 2 seasons of striker and then 2 of pace maybe 3.

Well I just plan loads of pace, no surprise there!

As I said though, after he random pops in technique and striker I may look at selling him on. Probably be the most profitable time to sell I would imagine.

B or R?
18 year old for pace and defence training - meant to be talented

poor stamina unsatisfactory keeper
average pace excellent defender
very good technique very good playmaker
poor passing adequate striker

£1.7 million
(edited)

He better be super talented or that is a robbed I'm afraid.

I have watched a couple of better 18 year old players lately with a couple higher total in the in Midfielder skills, and they sold for a slightly smaller amount.

191k...

a bit old perhaps.. but will get a season of tech & passing.. with a few decent randoms? straight out of youth school, but he's got to be fairly talented with that distribution..

Maciej Mierzeja , age 20
value: 88 800 £
wage: 1 110 £
very good form

unsatisfactory stamina hopeless keeper
excellent pace weak defender
weak technique excellent playmaker
solid passing adequate striker

Nice buy I think. ;)

cheers! I thought so, but it's always nice to have a second opinion!

Been overhauling my reserves and bought these 3 players:

Alfred Gran, age: 19, country: Sverige
value: 111 300 £, wage: 1 140 £
weak form, unsatisfactory tactical discipline
bookings:
average stamina tragic keeper
excellent pace unsatisfactory defender
solid technique solid playmaker
outstanding passing hopeless striker

He was 967k

Angelico Matteini, age: 18, country: Italia
value: 90 150 £, wage: 930 £
outstanding form, tragic tactical discipline

hopeless stamina tragic keeper
good pace excellent defender
excellent technique weak playmaker
adequate passing tragic striker

1.004m was he

Bogdan Peixe, age: 18, country: Brasil
value: 73 800 £, wage: 1 035 £
solid form, tragic tactical discipline

poor stamina tragic keeper
excellent pace poor defender
average technique hopeless playmaker
unsatisfactory passing excellent striker

364k

So which are they, b or r?
(edited)

Others will question my opinion though. ;) ....but they are just difficult people aka Dylanos and DJ. lol

I reckon the first one is a great buy, the other 2 to me look like robbed, more so on the 2nd one though imo. Others may disagree though, I just feel for over a million you would maybe want slithly better secondaries? What are you going to train?

Looks like you have been buying wisely.

They are all small bargains I reckon, decent buys.

£650k - probably robbed, won't be required for training so bought to be my mai8n keeper for the next 2 seasons, and eventually my reserve keeper I would think.

Adrian Miąskiewicz, age: 28
value: 447 000 £, wage: 7 215 £
club: Longfield Tigers, country: Polska
poor form, adequate tactical discipline

formidable stamina, formidable keeper
unearthly pace, average defender
average technique, weak playmaker
outstanding passing, average striker

2 seasons worth then he is fine...my only worry would be if he sticks in bad form, but otherwise he is a cracking keeper.

It's an ok price. But i'd want the keeper to be higher than that in your division and with that wage.

I have only an excellent keeper at the moment with much less pace and passing.......does ok, but hopefully this guy will do better in some instances?

Of course. I have got by with just a solid 'keeper since i joined (who fairly recently popped to very good) and he does OK in III. I just feel perhaps he might be a tad weak for II...he certainly isn't going to lose any races.