Subject: Bargain or Robbed? You decide

I can't accept that fact. What would I do with my time ? Work ?

Thats just clever trading though, not really a training plan.

you take that back, how dare you use the c word ;)

If you sell at 25 as a 4x magical + another high skill then they have to be worth more than a 24 yr old with 2 X magical and brilliant and less.

would imagine a 25yr old 4x magical is worth a fortune. i wonder if phil was thinking they would be older?

I have these 2 and expected them to make it by mid 25

age: 24

very good stamina unsatisfactory keeper
magical pace incredible defender
incredible technique very good playmaker
brilliant passing adequate striker

age: 24

formidable stamina tragic keeper
magical pace brilliant defender
excellent technique solid playmaker
incredible passing solid striker

If they are 24 now the first guy needs 5 pops, and the second guy needs 8 pops.

Thats a lot in a season at their age.

the first 1 should make it before he hits 26, but the second 1 won't

so, should they be sold now or when?

the first will be 3 X magical by this time next season and the second should hit unearthly defender in 7 weeks
(edited)

if you sell, can you replace them with better ? do you want to win the league, or just train up players and make money ?

i quite like having players this good who should get better and be 70+ midfielders regularly. Iwas just wondering what others will do.

I'd love to have your dilemma :). I'd keep them.

Thats my feeling. I also have Blunsden, a Norge NT player and a Peru national team winger who are all 23 and uber. plus 4 NT potential yths.

Provided you're bringing through players of enough quality to enable you to replace the older ones, I can't see the problem.

if you check out my FA cup games then by next season (maybe week 3-4) I should be able to sell both of the 24yr olds and buy in 2 yths and still have players who can play in the first team.

Actually, looking at your first 11, I'd be tempted to go and get another 5 million pound striker to go with the 7* guy, and then you'll blitz your league, and be close to Premiership strength.