Subject: Help with calculating talent

Hi guys looking for a bit of help here, i have put these 2 youth pulls on the TL

The proof of talent i have is incorrect, as they both popped at higher skills than the graphs i have from sokker viewer. Here is the info i have posted on the both

14900358

Phil Chalmers, age: 17
club: The Hoops, country: Scotland
value: 30 000 £, wage: 465 £
outstanding form, tragic tactical discipline


unsatisfactory stamina tragic keeper

average pace good defender
average technique hopeless playmaker
good passing hopeless striker

I think his talent is around 4 with a brilliant coach

here is the only graph of his skills i have

TALENT

he popped on 17-09-2009 as Very Good


14813744

Jocky Dunn, age: 17
club: The Hoops, country: Scotland
value: 35 850 £, wage: 585 £
good form, tragic tactical discipline


average stamina tragic keeper
average pace tragic defender
unsatisfactory technique adequate playmaker
very good passing average striker

pretty sure his talent is 4 with brilliant coach

here is the only graph i have of his skills

TALENT

he popped as Formidable on the 10-09-2009 according to my notes

i have also found this picture of another youth player which shows the 2 youths above just before they popped and were pulled, showing Jocky Dunn the day before he popped to Formidable and was pulled and Phil Chalmers a week and a day before he popped to Very Good and was pulled

YOUTHS

any help would be appreciated as i have a bit of interest in them both and would love to be accurate with there talents

I don't use any programmes so I'm not 100% sure if I'm reading it right but looking at what you posted, the screen shots are telling us that they are 4 weekers. "Average pop 4"

That's also backed up with that "youth" screenshot. Dunn is showing as excellent +1 then on his screen it says he was pulled with excellent +2 and also "average pop 4"

Or have i got your question wrong?

Don't suppose you took a screenshot with plus before you pulled them?

It's the best way to prove talent really.

got it slightly wrong mate but thanks for the reply

he was pulled at Formidable and the other very good, on the sokker viewer screenshot, it shows both there talents, skills etc as if they were pulled 2 weeks earlier, although the exit date shown on the picture is correct

dont know why but sokker viewer is not showing that, i am trying to be accurate but i reckon they are both 4 talent