Subject: Best Scottish Players Age 22+

Goalkeepers

keeper x2
Pace x1.5
Passing x0.5

[ pid=ID Player]Name Player[/pid] - team name - [ b]skillpoints[/b]


Age 22-25

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Age 26+

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Defenders


defender, pace x 1.5
passing, playmaking, technique x1
stamina x 0.75

[ pid=ID Player]Name Player[/pid] - team name - [ b]skillpoints[/b]

Age 22-25


1. Murray Burdon - KS Kepno - 88.50
2. Robert Berry - Armoton Kanuuna - 81.25
3. Derek Bear - Armoton Kanuuna - 78.75
4. Kieran MacLean - Fozza Torrese - 76.25
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.

Age 26+

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------


Midfielders

Passing & playmaking x1.5
Technique, pace & defending x1
Stamina x0.5
Scoring x0.25

[ pid=ID Player]Name Player[/pid] - team name - [ b]skillpoints[/b]

Age 22-25

1. Murray Burdon - KS Kepno - 86.00
2. Andy MacKilligan - Tartan Terrors - 84.75
3. Alexander Hughes - Tartan Terrors - 81.75
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.

Age 26+

1. Samuel Nisbet - Tartan Terrors - 98.25
2. Conor Barclay - FC Beers - 98
3. Callum Mathie - Yo Yo - 94.25
4. Collin Stalker - FC Beers - 89.75
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.



---------------------------------------------------------------------------


Wingers

Passing, Technique & pace x1.5
playmaking x1
defending & Scoring x0.5
Stamina x0.25

[ pid=ID Player]Name Player[/pid] - team name - [ b]skillpoints[/b]

Age 22-25

1. Owen Coulson - Tartan Terrors - 89.50
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.

Age 26+

1. Samuel Nisbet - Tartan Terrors - 101.75
2. Conor Barclay - FC Beers - 100.25
3. Collin Stalker - FC Beers - 91.75
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------


Strikers

technique, pace, striker x1.5
defending x1
Passing & playmaking x0.5
Stamina x0.25

[ pid=ID Player]Name Player[/pid] - team name - [ b]skillpoints[/b]

Age 22-25

1. Kieran Morren - Patchies Eleven - 87.50
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.

Age 26+

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.


...



(edited)
(edited)
(edited)

Having encouraged Stevie to get a list of the best Scottish U21 players. To try and encourage training as some people like to know how well their trainee is doing compared to others.

Its only logical we have the best 22yo and older players listed.

Couple of things Ive not liked with these things before.

1. Didn't agree with the points allocation.
2. As Wingers are a different animal to midfielders they should have their own category.

Post them in this format

Category
Age ??
[ pid=ID Player]Name Player[/pid] - team name - [ b]skillpoints[/b]


Cheers.
(edited)

RE: Points allocation - at the risk of sounding nubbish/arseholey... are we not better having the same total of multipliers for each position?

I know there's only a quarter stat between outfield positions (GK:4 DEF:6.5 MID:6.5 WING:6.75 ATT: 6.75), but that quarter stat could make all the difference for a player like Jock Manson. #JockofallTrades #MansonforScotland

Interesting point, give me a minute.

Stamina calc adjusted for Defenders and Midfielders to get multiplyer symetry excluding goalkeepers as they are a different breed anyway!

with your calcs mate you will never have a winger better than a mid. If i place Vaughan in both categories he will clearly come out as a better mid than a winger - though we all know he is a winger.

Im not worried about comparing points across categories, only comparing within the category.

Post Vaughan in both, thats ok. Im gonna with Nisbet, these players will score high in both. But really they are wingers. If we have a lot of top central mids they might not score so high up.

I was thinking of putting a minimum requirements for certain skills within a category but not at the moment.

I have hopes Vaughan will become a center mid anyway, hopes...


I will kick off with these two punters:

Winger
Age 31
[ pid=6301588]Samuel Nisbet[/pid] - Tartan Terrors - [ b]101.75[/b]

Winger
Age 26
[ pid=11259275]Owen Coulson[/pid] - Tartan Terrors - [ b]89.50[/b]

(edited)

Actually Ive waited the big three winger skills so it might not be as disadvantaged to wingers as you think.

Midfielder
Age 31
[ pid=6301588]Samuel Nisbet[/pid] - Tartan Terrors - [ b]98.25[/b]

Does score less points as a mid, that is kinda what Id like to see, but not so important as comparing him with other midfielder or winger scores seperately.
(edited)

Midfielder
Age 30

[ pid=6054439]Callum Mathie[/pid]-Yo Yo -[ b]94.25[/b]

Defender
Age 22

[ pid=13738907]Derek Bear[/pid]- Armoton Kanuuna -[ b]78.75[/b]


Defender
Age 25

[ pid=12445068]Robert Berry[/pid]- Armoton Kanuuna -[ b]81.25[/b]

---

Defender
Age 24

[ pid=11537088]Bruce Neeson[/pid] - F.C. Diablo - [ b]83,75[/b]

(edited)

Defender
Age 25

[ pid=10382492]Kieran MacLean[/pid] - Fozza Torrese - [ b]76,25[/b]

MID
Age: 29
[pid=7851083]Conor Barclay[/pid ] - FC Beers - [b]98[/b ]
Age: 26
[pid=9435538]Collin Stalker[/pid ] - FC Beers - [b]89.75[/b ]

WING:
Age: 29
[pid=7851083]Conor Barclay[/pid ] - FC Beers - [b]100.25[/b ]
Age: 26
[pid=9435538]Collin Stalker[/pid ] - FC Beers - [b]91.75[/b ]