Subject: VALUATIONS thread

i'd say he was worth 700k

Tjorven Siebers, age: 19
value: 71 700 £, wage: 810 £
club: The Super Furry Gerbils, country: België
good form, average tactical discipline


average stamina, tragic keeper
formidable pace, hopeless defender
solid technique, hopeless playmaker
hopeless passing, solid striker

£200k, depending on talent?

A bit more than that I would say, perhaps around 600k I guess.

It probably is, isn'it it? I am a bit ribbish :o)

yeah i got 700k in juniors so around that range i should think! he popped in pace the first week i got him :) but might see how long he takes to get to outstanding

Philip Henson, age 19
value: 70 650 £, wage: 900 £
good form

solid stamina, tragic keeper
poor pace, solid defender
formidable technique, hopeless playmaker
hopeless passing, good striker

Ronald Matthews, age 20
value: 97 650 £, wage: 1 035 £
formidable form

weak stamina, poor keeper
poor pace, weak defender
excellent technique, good playmaker
average passing, excellent striker

Rick Surgeon, age 19
value: 87 150 £, wage: 750 £
divine form

average stamina, hopeless keeper
solid pace, very good defender
very good technique, unsatisfactory playmaker
unsatisfactory passing, poor striker


Riley Tuff, age 19
value: 124 950 £, wage: 1 245 £
very good form

adequate stamina, adequate keeper
formidable pace, good defender
average technique, solid playmaker
average passing, very good striker


Anton Wanlace, age 17
value: 60 000 £, wage: 585 £
divine form

good stamina, hopeless keeper
weak pace, weak defender
weak technique, excellent playmaker
adequate passing, unsatisfactory striker

Interested to know how much these 5 are worth.

Philip Henson, age 19 - 350k
Ronald Matthews, age 20 - 300k
Rick Surgeon, age 19 - 150k
Riley Tuff, age 19 - 700k
Anton Wanlace, age 17 - 200k

Henson - £300-£400k? Not very appealing to a def trainer due to no passing or pm. Striker trainer doing pace & striker would like him I suppose.

Matthews - £650-£800k? Very nice looking trainee for a pace trainer.

Surgeon - £200-£300k? Same as Henson really, apart from he is only really a def trainee. Just not a very good one though :(

Tuff - £400-£500k? Very nice trainee for a tech trainer.

Wanlace - £200-£300k? Looks like a very nice trainee for a def trainer, pm and passing would look very appealing to someone like me :)

Talent, with proof if possible, would push the prices up of course.

Not too much difference really, except for Matthews. I would trust Phil_Fox's judgment on that one, he has more experience about buying that kind of player.

i'll give you £200-300k valuation for anton wanlace

Ye, well I compared him to this dude I bought recently:

Cost 362k

Stuart MacRobie, age: 18
value: 78 750 £, wage: 990 £
club: Phils_hotspurs, country: Scotland
excellent form, hopeless tactical discipline

adequate stamina, unsatisfactory keeper
unsatisfactory pace, weak defender
excellent technique, unsatisfactory playmaker
unsatisfactory passing, excellent striker

I would have thought that Matthews would go for about £100k more due to having better secondaries. But then again he is 2years older too.
(edited)

Ye, well I would personally say two extra years of training potential should be much more important!

I agree with you, I only saw how old he was after I posted the first time :)

this question is a bit off the topic but can we advertise other people's players for them, because my friend is busy for like the whole week and he cant advertise so i suggested that i would do it for him, is it allowed?