Subject: VALUATIONS thread

Chenaro Marcos Madera , age 21
value: 111 150 £
wage: 1 155 £
excellent form

solid stamina tragic keeper
very good pace good defender
excellent technique poor playmaker
adequate passing very good striker

Stanisław Kula , age 24
value: 103 800 £
wage: 1 425 £
hopeless form

excellent stamina hopeless keeper
formidable pace weak defender
excellent technique adequate playmaker
average passing very good striker

any ideas on these 2?

New youth player today. 17yr excellent keeper. Any Ideas on a valuation?

He was a 5 week talent with brilliant youth coach

Jenson Maudesley, age 17
value: 150 600 £
wage: 1 845 £
very good form

hopeless stamina excellent keeper
good pace hopeless defender
tragic technique hopeless playmaker
hopeless passing hopeless striker

Thanks

Fresh youth pull - came out Solid+1, talent 6 with Formidable YC

Jake Hakin, age: 16 club: Busby`s Babes, country: England
value: 20 250 £, wage: 390 £
very good form, tragic tactical discipline

hopeless stamina hopeless keeper
average pace adequate defender
poor technique hopeless playmaker
average passing weak striker

Worth much?
(edited)

Any ideas on this guy?

magical+0, 3.33 talent:

Dylan Brazier, age: 18 club: Jotun ISK, country: England
value: 80 400 £, wage: 1 035 £
very good form, tragic tactical discipline


adequate stamina hopeless keeper
excellent pace very good defender
solid technique average playmaker
poor passing average striker


And this one? +5 pace

Szczęsny Zwierzyński, age: 23 club: Jotun ISK, country: Polska
value: 272 250 £, wage: 3 585 £
hopeless form, brilliant tactical discipline
bookings:

formidable stamina hopeless keeper
magical pace adequate defender
formidable technique solid playmaker
adequate passing outstanding striker
(edited)

age: 25
club: villa stars, country: Norge
value: 290 700 £, wage: 3 585 £
very good form, outstanding tactical discipline
bookings:

formidable stamina tragic keeper
incredible pace outstanding defender
excellent technique outstanding playmaker
good passing weak striker

can any1 value this player ....please... thanx

Madera £400k - £850k
Kula £250k - £500k
Maudesley £175k - £375k
Hakin £40k-£175k (so varied these players) Humphreys had the exact same talent but looked like this when i sold him to toonmac for £236k, he was pulled a week or 2 before the new season though:

George Humphreys, age: 16
club: Armitage Shanks, country: England
value: 30 750 £, wage: 495 £
very good form, tragic tactical discipline

hopeless stamina hopeless keeper
average pace average defender
average technique weak playmaker
average passing good striker

Brazier £1m - £1.75m
Zwierzyński, lots maybe £1.75m+
villa stars' last player, lots maybe £750k - £1.25m

Nobody likes having a go at valuations much in England do they?
(edited)

Thanks for replying Jimmy. I dont know what you exactly mean by talent ( I am pretty new ) , but if you mean from the way he persorms then from what I have seen him play during games he seems to be improving rapidly.

Thanks a lot for answering with a valuation.

How do you reckon much for this chap

Augustin Bărzoi, Age: 22
Value: 211 750 $,   Salary: 2 125 $
Team: MK Johns,   Country: România
Form: divine (17)
Stamina: formidable (11),   Keeper: tragic (0)
Pace: solid (8),   Defender: solid (8)
Technique: solid (8),   Playmaker: poor (3)
Passing: adequate (6),   Striker: adequate (6)

jumped to solid def in 5 weeks.

not much, less than 100k and he is not even talented

any idea what this guy is worth?

Luke Blayney, age: 23
club: Celtic Wanderers, country: England
value: 234 900 £, wage: 2 145 £
formidable form, formidable tactical discipline
bookings:

adequate stamina tragic keeper
excellent pace formidable defender
outstanding technique formidable playmaker
formidable passing unsatisfactory striker

Hrm... he's going to pay for a coach next season for me though.

age 28
value: 369 450 £
wage: 3 660 £
formidable stamina hopeless keeper
incredible pace adequate defender
excellent technique good playmaker
solid passing outstanding striker

I bought him recent and just wondering if i paid too much....

I don't think 5 weeks to solid DEF at 22 is that untalented, but still, i think £50k for Barzoi
Blayney £1.7m-£2.4m
roberto_b75's player £750k-£950k
(edited)

Thanks, i paid 705k so good news :-) he went for 1.3 the transfer before that 2 months ago.

That's a pretty reasonable price, just don't expect to make a profit if/when you sell on ;o)

Haha i was going to sell him at the end of the season to try get my money back. Bought him 2 do a job and buy time to develop my youngsters.