Subject: VALUATIONS thread

ah, well, when you put it like that...

....and you've been playing far longer than me....tut tut. ;)

i'm more forgetful than what you are.

You are surely younger than me.......

No, just more immature.

could someone please evaluate this player for me?

Geoffrey Hancocks, age 19
value: 81 000 £
wage: 930 £
formidable form

average stamina hopeless keeper
very good pace very good defender
adequate technique solid playmaker
weak passing unsatisfactory striker

150-200k?

maybe slightly more with a little luck?

ANy idea on these 2

Emilio Vettori, age: 19
club: Celtic Wanderers, country: Italia
value: 192 150 £, wage: 3 165 £
tragic form, very good tactical discipline


average stamina outstanding keeper
excellent pace unsatisfactory defender
unsatisfactory technique hopeless playmaker
poor passing unsatisfactory striker

Arild Michelsen, age: 19
club: Celtic Wanderers, country: Danmark
value: 111 150 £, wage: 1 305 £
adequate form, good tactical discipline


good stamina average keeper
excellent pace excellent defender
average technique average playmaker
solid passing very good striker
(and with formidable pace and defender) and

The GK I would guess £1m and the defender around 350k?

I am a bit rough on gk estimates though......well most etimates really. lol

350k. you are having me on I paid 900k last season I was expecting close to 1mil

I am not having you on, I did say I was probably wrong......I maybe wrong but 1m+ as he is is probably not possible. As a formidable/form maybe.

I would wait on other valuations though as I am probably wrong.

thats cool, just everyone said he was a good buy at the end of last season and I can't see him being worth so little now. Hopefully someone else will disagree with you

Hopefully someone will, I try to give honest valuations....sometimes though I just spout barnacles. ;)

No-one ever listens when I say that you should buy youth at the start of the season, not at the end when conventional wisdom says prices are lowest!!

What valuation do you give the defender and keeper though? Am I way out?