Subject: VALUATIONS thread

Last week a 21yo winger with worse skills sold for a crazy 4.7 million.

Paulică Rucăreanu, age: 21
club: Diamond Sharks, country: România
value: 421 500 £, wage: 3 345 £
magical form, formidable tactical discipline
bookings:

good stamina tragic keeper
incredible pace good defender
incredible technique formidable playmaker
incredible passing average striker

Both of these guys are currently at outstanding technique but they will be sold week 1/2 of next season when they reach incredible. Any ideas how much they will fetch?

Kane Speed, age: 24
club: World AllStars XI, country: England
value: 467 850 £, wage: 4 995 £
incredible form, incredible tactical discipline

formidable stamina tragic keeper
unearthly pace weak defender
incredible technique poor playmaker
good passing outstanding striker



Maurycy Częścik, age: 23
club: World AllStars XI, country: Polska
value: 225 600 £, wage: 3 015 £
unsatisfactory form, incredible tactical discipline

solid stamina hopeless keeper
incredible pace weak defender
incredible technique adequate playmaker
good passing brilliant striker

Nazareno Herrera, age: 19
value: 131 250 $, wage: 1 125 $
club: Mushroomhead, country: Argentina
superdivine form, adequate tactical discipline

solid stamina, hopeless keeper
solid pace, very good defender
poor technique, average playmaker
good passing, unsatisfactory striker

Omar Ibarra, age: 19
value: 99 750 $, wage: 900 $
club: Mushroomhead, country: México
divine form, adequate tactical discipline

weak stamina, tragic keeper
very good pace, very good defender
unsatisfactory technique, average playmaker
weak passing, tragic striker

Any ideas on values?? Trying to decide whether or not to sell now or wait til the overly inflated market in 2-3 weeks.

valuation please...

age: 20
formidable stamina, tragic keeper
formidable pace, poor defender
formidable technique, solid playmaker
unsatisfactory passing, solid striker

Don't know JS talent, but took 4 weeks to Formidable Pace last season
(edited)

I'd guess at 2.5 million for Speed, and 3 million + for Częścik. If Speed had brilliant striker on the other hand, you could put another 1 - 1.5 mill on to his value.

I should point out that I haven't bought strikers for a while - others may have a better idea.

2.5m for Speed sounds about right. I sold a virtually identical player recently for that price.

As I am totally hopeless on valuing my own players, could somebody give me an idea on this guy please?

Mieczysław Herbski, age: 23

club: Longfield Tigers, country: Polska
value: 624 450 £, wage: 6 690 £
outstanding form, incredible tactical discipline
bookings:
excellent stamina tragic keeper
divine pace very good defender
magical technique adequate playmaker
solid passing incredible striker

dude - train him up to magical striker. Then sell. Seriously.

I am not planning on selling before then really, I just wondered what he maybe worth right now?

Bragging more like, take him and flowers as high in striker as you can.

seconded.

LOL seriously I am not bragging as he is by far my best player and you have a fair few more valuable players I would imagine. ;)

I really would like to have some sort of valuation though as it helps to motivate me in training further sometimes.....if that makes sense. Flowers will be much more long term than herbski now though who I imagine I will be selling at hopefully Divine, Unearthly + Unearthly. Hopefully I can make Flowers a full nt player one day.

I'd say herbiski is at the 5mil level and would be worth two more with magical striker

Agreed, the only comparable player that I have I bought for 4 million when he was 22. Herbski is definitely worth between 5 and 7 million, and can only get more expensive with training. I wouldn't think about selling before divine / unearthly / unearthly.
(edited)

I know he's not in the same league as Herbski et al, but any chance of a valutaion on my player. Cheers

With solid striker you're unlikely to get anything above 500k at a guess. I'd train him up to formidable striker to be honest. In the time that takes you might pick up a pace or tech pop, and then you'll be looking at about a million as a guess.