Subject: VALUATIONS thread

With solid striker you're unlikely to get anything above 500k at a guess. I'd train him up to formidable striker to be honest. In the time that takes you might pick up a pace or tech pop, and then you'll be looking at about a million as a guess.

cheers, I'll train on then.

3.33 YP Talent

Klaudiusz Murarczyk, age: 23

club: Phils_hotspurs, country: Polska
value: 708 600 £, wage: 5 490 £
divine form, formidable tactical discipline

NTDB:
formidable stamina tragic keeper
unearthly+4 pace solid defender
incredible+1 technique average playmaker
adequate passing magical striker

could someone evaluate these 3 for me please?

Edelzio Penha , age 21
value: 108 150 £
wage: 1 485 £
weak form
bookings:
formidable stamina tragic keeper
very good pace weak defender
excellent technique good playmaker
very good passing hopeless striker

Ronnie Reader, age 22
value: 272 550 £
wage: 2 625 £
divine form

formidable stamina hopeless keeper
incredible pace good defender
adequate technique outstanding playmaker
adequate passing poor striker

Bártolo Velho da Costa , age 22
value: 94 650 £
wage: 1 035 £
average form

very good stamina tragic keeper
formidable pace poor defender
excellent technique good playmaker
solid passing average striker

I'd say in the region of 150k each, maybe a bit more.

No idea, but I would guess at around 4m?

Why would you sell that player ? Didn't he win you the Prem ?

Once he hits divine pace there is no need for phil to keep him. as he is still kinda trainable, phil might as well sell for a profit.

I only train pace, there has to come a point where I sell....

I am looking for a bit more than 4 million!

surprise me, Mr. "I am looking for a bit more than <insert current value here>"

Well, 5ish million

I make that FPI + 12 % !

any ideas for the prices of these 2?

Ian Evered, age 20
value: 70 950 £
wage: 780 £
outstanding form

unsatisfactory stamina unsatisfactory keeper
good pace unsatisfactory defender
very good technique average playmaker
unsatisfactory passing very good striker

Kuba Ewertowski , age 21
value: 127 950 £
wage: 1 725 £
adequate form

formidable stamina tragic keeper
outstanding pace weak defender
very good technique poor playmaker
average passing good striker

hmm - tricky. I dont' think you'll make a great deal until they are trained further. evered needs pace initially. I would train him until he hits 3 * formidable. He could do that by 22 I reckon. Then you'll get a nice sum. Ewertowski would need at least excellent striker and technique to generate some cash. Ideally, you'd sell him at 3 * outstanding or better, maybe by the time he hits late 23 ?

It depends on how your training is set up though, and how they fit into that. I'd guess at 250k for each of them as it stands, maybe less for ewertowski as his only real skill is pace.

Cezary Burczyk, age: 21
value: 354 450 £, wage: 2 700 £
club: Diamond Sharks, country: Polska
magical form, excellent tactical discipline

average stamina, unsatisfactory keeper
formidable pace, excellent defender
outstanding technique, formidable playmaker
outstanding passing, formidable striker

Thor Liverød, age: 21
value: 318 300 £, wage: 3 405 £
club: Diamond Sharks, country: Norge
poor form, outstanding tactical discipline

good stamina, hopeless keeper
magical pace, formidable defender
incredible technique, solid playmaker
formidable passing, weak striker

Paulică Rucăreanu, age: 21
value: 453 150 £, wage: 3 345 £
club: Diamond Sharks, country: România
divine form, formidable tactical discipline

good stamina, tragic keeper
incredible pace, good defender
incredible technique, formidable playmaker
incredible passing, average striker

Jens Chriske, age: 18
club: Diamond Sharks, country: Deutschland
value: 130 350 £, wage: 990 £
formidable form, solid tactical discipline

average stamina unsatisfactory keeper
very good pace average defender
very good technique excellent playmaker
excellent passing unsatisfactory striker
(edited)

A lot of money, hard to say exactly!!