Subject: VALUATIONS thread

hello guys, I'm going to list this guy..have been unable to find a comparison skill wise of the same age so have no idea what to start at...any suggestions?

cheers

Kauri Masing , age 20
value: 183 750 £
wage: 1 650 £
superdivine form

weak stamina tragic keeper
outstanding pace solid defender
solid technique very good playmaker
adequate passing solid striker

Can somebody please give me a valuation on both sets of skills please, I am trying to decide whether its worth training further in striking.....

Both 25 yr olds.

formidable stamina tragic keeper
divine pace excellent defender
unearthly technique good playmaker
very good passing magical striker

formidable stamina tragic keeper
divine pace excellent defender
unearthly technique good playmaker
very good passing unearthly striker

Thanks in advance.

right, not the greatest with valuations, so sorry if they're not what you expected, but no one else has done it, so i'll give it a go
@ ted thomas: about 200-250k decent talent would push price up
@ ncn: about 1mill??
@ 72monsta: quite nicely rounded maybe 750k-1 mill
@ wdp: quite a lot, 5 mill?? i think the extra level in striker would push the price by up to another 500k perhaps?

what about him? will probably go to outstanding pace in the next 1 or 2 trainings.

Rudolf Silnicki, age: 23
club: real toms tits, country: Polska
value: 242 850 £, wage: 2 235 £
superdivine form, excellent tactical discipline

formidable stamina tragic keeper
formidable pace solid defender
formidable technique average playmaker
very good passing solid striker

Your guy be about 1m roughly I would think. I'd be pretty gutted with just 5m for my guy.

thanks, as i said not great with valuations, i don't really have much of an idea about those sort of players, as don't have one, and not got the sort of money to be looking at them on the transfer market. i still think another level of striker will add quite a bit to his value though

Yes I agree, I have been told around 8m elsewhere, and up to 9m with unearthly striker. This is my first and only player at this sort of level, it will hurt me selling him.... :(

I'd say around 7.5mil for the striker either way depends on how many you get interested before

i would pay 5 million for him no doubts, he should be worth a couple more i would think (having said that never bought such a player...)

I will ensure I drum up interest asap. My whole development depends upon it. ;)

He'd make a nice addition to any new prem team.........hint hint. lol
(edited)

would you guys pay 4.5 million for this chap?

is 5 weeks to brilliant tech a good talent?

21yo

weak stamina, hopeless keeper
outstanding+2 pace, adequate defender
brilliant+4 technique, good playmaker
excellent passing, incredible+1 striker

Not particularly goo I wouldn't think, but he seems a reasonable player overall. 4.5m seems a bit steep to me, but I could be wrong. Stamina is also a bad point imo.

agreed a 4.2 million starting bid...

hope to get him for that, long term investement

Fair enough. ;)

Clayton Alford, age: 19
value: 118 650 £, wage: 1 185 £
club: Slackers FC, country: England
excellent form, very good tactical discipline

good stamina, unsatisfactory keeper
solid pace, solid defender
solid technique, weak playmaker
excellent passing, excellent striker

incredible (+3/3.8)
Actual weeks per pop - 3*,4,4,4,3,4,4,+3
Average weeks per pop - 3.8
Screenshot

Pace +2 and general training; is near pop
Technique +1

Want to shift him and looking for starting offers. Have no idea what he's worth. Can someone tell me?

Jacob Madge, age: 16
value: 39 450 £, wage: 585 £
club: Buddha`s Boots, country: England
very good form, tragic tactical discipline

hopeless stamina, adequate keeper
adequate pace, tragic defender
tragic technique, tragic playmaker
good passing, tragic striker

unknown talent - came in adequate popped once --/---
any idea on value? would like to sell straight away as will not get trained by me

couple of quid maybe? I'd possibly take him off your hands for that.. ;-)

any idea on this one??

Dianbobo Arbonnier , age 23
value: 234 600 £
wage: 2 175 £
superdivine form
bookings:
formidable stamina tragic keeper
excellent pace outstanding defender
average technique unsatisfactory playmaker
formidable passing adequate striker

cheers!