Subject: VALUATIONS thread

How much are these two guys worth, both talented:

Gesualdo Ghinzani, age: 17 - currently the no1 italian keeper at 17
value: 130 200 £, wage: 1 095 £
unearthly form, good tactical discipline

unsatisfactory stamina very good keeper
good pace unsatisfactory defender
unsatisfactory technique unsatisfactory playmaker
solid passing hopeless striker

Dino Daini, age: 20
value: 627 750 £, wage: 5 820 £
unearthly form, formidable tactical discipline

good stamina brilliant keeper
formidable pace poor defender
poor technique unsatisfactory playmaker
good passing poor striker
(edited)

Any idea of how much I could get if I decided to sell this chap?

Brilliant +0 pull, 4 Wk Talent with Formidable then Outstanding YC.......

Ethan Doyle, Age 18
Value: 85 500 £
Wage: 1 065 £
Very Good Form

Unsatisfactory Stamina Poor Keeper
Very Good Pace Very Good Defender
Very Good Technique Solid Playmaker
Average Passing Poor Striker


(edited)
(edited)

£2m+

his talent is clearly better than 4 as he has a 3 week pop on that graph. i would guess with those coaches he is pretty much max talent.... now STOP. THINK. ASK. LOOK. THINK. ASK. STOP. THINK. LOOK. ASK. LOOK. SPEND.

I had a Formidable coach up until the last 9 weeks where I had an Outstanding YC. Ethan Doyle had a 5 week pop with the Formidable coach and the rest were 4 weekly and then with the Outstanding YC, he had a 3 week and a 4 week........ averages to a 4 week talent or near enough I believe :-)

I have proof of coach levels through Sokker Viewer if anybody would like to see proof.
(edited)
(edited)

For Ethan Doyle I'd suggest quite close to a million. I bought a similar player with worse secondaries for about 780k a few weeks back.

Definately worth at least £1.5m.

I sold an 18yr old last season for 1.869M, imo Ethan Doyle has better starting stats therefore I would expect 2M +

My player was like this........
Average Stamina Hopeless Keeper
Hopeless Pace Excellent Defender
Excellent Technique Solid Playmaker
Average Passing Poor Striker
Total skills = 38

Ethan's = 48.

sssssh :).

I have a plague of incredible to magicals due to arrive in the next 4 to 13 weeks. I'm hoping for some similar quality pulls in there somewhere..

must be terrible that, my best ever pull was outstanding, and the most profitable was formidable.

How is it possible to not get better than outstanding in over 4 1/2 years of playing? Do you not bother trying with your youth school?

ah - tell a lie, I did get an incredible once. And I currently have a magical youth coach. I get talented players too, just never of the 30 week variety.
(edited)

I had a good 28 pop up last week I think. They almost never turn out to be talented though. Average/Adequate arrivals seem to perform better for me.

how much for an 18 year old with these skills ?

unsatisfactory stamina hopeless keeper
excellent pace excellent defender
good technique poor playmaker
poor passing excellent striker

How much are these two guys worth, both talented:

Gesualdo Ghinzani, age: 17 - currently the no1 italian keeper at 17
value: 130 200 £, wage: 1 095 £
unearthly form, good tactical discipline

unsatisfactory stamina very good keeper
good pace unsatisfactory defender
unsatisfactory technique unsatisfactory playmaker
solid passing hopeless striker

Dino Daini, age: 20
value: 627 750 £, wage: 5 820 £
unearthly form, formidable tactical discipline

good stamina brilliant keeper
formidable pace poor defender
poor technique unsatisfactory playmaker
good passing poor striker

got missed so posted again, if that is against the rules please delete and use a big slipper on my behind as punishment :(