Subject: VALUATIONS thread

Hopefully somebody will answer this as I have a couple of similar players...

i'd say 300-400k depending on exact talent

hmm i'd say around 300k for kwazulu's. he's good but his pace is the highest by a mile, so less people will be interested in him. maybe a bit more if you put a talent graph up :)

Definately no more than £300k imo.

Any ideas on this guy? He is probably single trainings away from popping in tech and striker. Can't find his YS talent, but he took 6 weeks to brilliant pace.

Mason Cardwell, age: 22
club: Jotun ISK, country: England
value: 370 050 £, wage: 2 910 £
superdivine form, incredible tactical discipline


formidable stamina tragic keeper
brilliant pace good defender
excellent technique adequate playmaker
solid passing incredible striker

my mid training is now over, how much might this guy go for:

Dale Buxton, age: 23

club: AFC Denton Sharks, country: England
value: 209 400 £, wage: 2 430 £
average form, formidable tactical discipline

formidable stamina hopeless keeper
outstanding pace average defender
very good technique outstanding playmaker
very good passing very good striker

guessing at 500k, but more if you get his passing up 2 or 3 levels.

every season this guy has had an injury, and this delayed his improvement, his current skills is the skills are the best i could draw out of him which is a shame because he has the ability to have been better than what he is now.
(edited)

I remember him well as he had 4 YA Talent from me with a YC not that great maybe even Incredible?

So are you surprised about his skills now, did you expect him to have the skills he possesses now?

Not sure Ken as I know he was a low level pull and did not have great skills so I think he is probably about what I expected, either way you have done well with him and if you did put 2 or 3 more levels of passing he'd be worth a lot more. When I think back to how you uised to be in this game you have certainly grown. ;)

Thanks for your comments and this was his exact skills when I first bought him when he was 18:

poor stamina,
unsatisfactory pace, unsatisfactory defender
poor technique, very good playmaker
weak passing, good striker

not a bad player now if i do say so myself.

Yes you really did do well with him. :)

eriikr - £1.5 - 2mil ish, maybe more. Although he's exactly the sort of player I'd be looking for for my next two seasons training tech, so nearer £300k ;)

Anyone got any valuations for this little lot. All products from my youth school. Didn't record exact talent for any of them (as I've been busy with other things) but i'd expect it's below 5 weeks (as I don't keep any youngsters with a talent < 5 weeks).

Jonathon Benzit, age 19
value: 44 400 £
wage: 645 £
good form

weak stamina unsatisfactory keeper
weak pace solid defender
solid technique tragic playmaker
average passing average striker

Gareth Brendon, age 20
value: 192 000 £
wage: 1 950 £
solid form
bookings: injury: (13 days)
formidable stamina poor keeper
formidable pace excellent defender
formidable technique average playmaker
good passing weak striker

The only guy I have talent for. Popped in pace 9 times in 41 weeks (although slightly randomly - I think due to injuries)

Adam Huggett, age 18
value: 67 050 £
wage: 645 £
superdivine form

hopeless stamina hopeless keeper
good pace solid defender
very good technique tragic playmaker
weak passing hopeless striker

Vijay Lister, age 17
value: 40 050 £
wage: 555 £
weak form

unsatisfactory stamina hopeless keeper
solid pace good defender
average technique good playmaker
adequate passing weak striker

Bez Verrall, age 17
value: 55 950 £
wage: 630 £
unearthly form

hopeless stamina hopeless keeper
average pace very good defender
good technique tragic playmaker
adequate passing weak striker

Dennis Wickenden, age 18
value: 89 850 £
wage: 855 £
magical form

weak stamina hopeless keeper
very good pace excellent defender
weak technique unsatisfactory playmaker
good passing poor striker

Cedric Hale, age: 18
value: 224 000 $, wage: 1 700 $
club: Mushroomhead, country: USA
poor form, very good tactical discipline

average stamina, hopeless keeper
formidable pace, adequate defender
very good technique, adequate playmaker
outstanding passing, solid striker

3.29 talent is +2 full trainings in pace so should be only one/two more to Outstanding pace. Or would it be wise for me to train PM to say VG before selling? Intent is train PM/Tech next season. Am I shooting myself in the foot here if I list him before getting those four skills to 10+ each?

Looking to sell, but not sure what to ask for...
(edited)

how much for these

Davor Grabarević , age 24
value: 129 150 £
wage: 1 335 £
superdivine form
bookings:
solid stamina tragic keeper
outstanding pace good defender
adequate technique unsatisfactory playmaker
adequate passing unsatisfactory striker


Victoraş Trică , age 20
value: 139 200 £
wage: 1 290 £
superdivine form
bookings:
weak stamina tragic keeper
outstanding pace good defender
weak technique good playmaker
good passing weak striker

Jouni Vuojala , age 21
value: 149 250 £
wage: 1 620 £
outstanding form

solid stamina very good keeper
excellent pace weak defender
weak technique poor playmaker
average passing poor striker