Subject: VALUATIONS thread

@ sty007

As things stand you haven't got any indication OR proof of talent ...yet.

As has been mentioned, you need the time taken from one pop to the next to prove talent - he could already have been part way to both the tech and pace pops.

So suggesting talent of 1 week and 2 weeks respectively, would be naive at best...

from last owner he sold after popping to good pace which tooks two weeks,i then trained pace for three weeks and he popped the second week, as for striker he said he trained striker for only two weeks and then when i trained he popped on the first week which said to me he took three weeks to excellent striker

Fair enough, thats what he told you.

However, I'd be a little cautious as it seems strange that they were willing to sell such a talented player for not a lot - if it were me I'd have kept training him, as in a season or 2 he could really have cashed in.

Going back to the point - the valuation - to put it bluntly, you have no proof. So you'd be selling the player on spec, therefore the 'without proof of talent' estimate is your best guide to what you'll get for him.

Good luck anyway.
(edited)

how much could i get without the proof

I'd say between 250 and 450k

hi, do you think he's worth 139k?

Kieran Pollaris, age: 22
club: tg logresti, country: België
value: 139 800 £, wage: 1 305 £
brilliant [14] form, good [7] tactical discipline
height: 183 cm


weak [4] stamina hopeless [1] keeper
formidable [11] pace unsatisfactory [2] defender
excellent [10] technique good [7] playmaker
unsatisfactory [2] passing solid [8] striker

Yep.

He could well cost the double. Roughly estimated value 250 000 $ to 450 000 $. Depends on talent and wheter its made public or not.

any ideas if I list friday?

Wacław Muraś, age: 26
club: Celtic Wanderers, country: Polska
value: 712 350 £, wage: 9 135 £
excellent form, brilliant tactical discipline
height: 183 cm
bookings:

excellent stamina tragic keeper
unearthly pace unearthly defender
formidable technique excellent playmaker
incredible passing very good striker

Pennies, right?

Riku Viljava , age 17
value: 31 950 £
wage: 390 £
unearthly form
bookings:
unsatisfactory stamina hopeless keeper
adequate pace adequate defender
average technique poor playmaker
poor passing average striker

yep 4k max

Och, I'll sell him anyway. I need decent trainees.

if you train pace he is fine. Any idea of pace talent? if he gets a couple of randoms and has decent pace with a talent graph then you can sell for a couple hundred k

His talent is like 4 to adequate.
I'll just neglect to mention that :)

Then get rid.

How about this guy? Popped in tech and playmaking this week, which makes three tech pops in 6 weeks. Cheers.

Bright Lines, age: 17
club: Jotun ISK, country: England
value: 59 250 £, wage: 615 £
outstanding form, good tactical discipline
height: 173 cm


tragic stamina tragic keeper
unsatisfactory pace solid defender
solid technique good playmaker
very good passing poor striker

And this one too..

Herwig Martic, age: 25
club: Jotun ISK, country: België
value: 760 650 £, wage: 9 495 £
very good form, outstanding tactical discipline
height: 186 cm
bookings: injury: (slight injury)

formidable stamina hopeless keeper
divine pace solid defender
incredible technique very good playmaker
excellent passing magical striker


(edited)

And some more trash, 1k quality?

Daniele Nagai , age 18
value: 63 750 £
wage: 675 £
magical form
bookings:
formidable stamina tragic keeper
average pace average defender
adequate technique average playmaker
poor passing average striker