Subject: VALUATIONS thread

I want to improve my dfenders and feel that I have better midfielders to cover for the first guy. If I can sell them then I would have 4mil for 2 defenders adn could sell another guy for roughly a mil and improve my forwards. Obviously that only works if I get enough money

the big problem I have is knowing what the starting prices should be, you got any idea?

You should advertise them until you get one or two starting offers.

All four players have very decent talent, talent which can be proved, but I have been buying extra players so need to get rid of a couple of trainees.

Would be interested in valuations:

John Broadbent, age: 17
value: 38 700 £, wage: 450 £
club: Phils_hotspurs, country: England
brilliant form, good tactical discipline

poor stamina, tragic keeper
average pace, adequate defender
adequate technique, good playmaker
adequate passing, tragic striker

Joerg Brammer, age: 19
value: 132 150 £, wage: 1 515 £
club: Phils_hotspurs, country: Deutschland
formidable form, solid tactical discipline

formidable stamina, tragic keeper
solid pace, good defender
solid technique, excellent playmaker
unsatisfactory passing, solid striker

Ingo Springer, age: 21
value: 63 450 £, wage: 840 £
club: Phils_hotspurs, country: Österreich
weak form, good tactical discipline

poor stamina, hopeless keeper
good pace, average defender
very good technique, good playmaker
good passing, very good striker

Hipólito Reynoso, age: 18
value: 61 050 £, wage: 615 £
club: Phils_hotspurs, country: Argentina
very good form, solid tactical discipline

poor stamina, tragic keeper
very good pace, solid defender
average technique, average playmaker
solid passing, unsatisfactory striker
(edited)

John Broadbent = 70k
Joerg Brammer = 150k
Ingo Springer = 200k
Hipólito Reynoso = 300k

Am not good at this but am trying all I can

Well, its nice to get valuations from you Ken, I know you do try.

To be honest though, I would be mortified if they sold for those prices, very cheap I would think.

Anyone else have an opinion?

i just noticed they are too low, if i had those players, I wouldn't like my players going for that much

So, anyone else have a valuation?

John Broadbent - £250-£300k

Joerg Brammer - £250-£300k (low estimate, but good secondaries may push the price up)

Ingo Springer - £400-£500k (nicely rounded so maybe more)

Hipólito Reynoso - £300-£400k (nice def trainee, would be alot more if PM was two or 3 levels higher)

Hipólito Reynoso I just refused a bid of 800-900k for him, I guess I value him higher!!

John Broadbent = 150k - 200K
Joerg Brammer = 300k - 350K
Ingo Springer = 500k - 600K
Hipólito Reynoso = 550K - 650K (Bought an 18yo with a similar blend of skills 2 weeks ago for 570K)

Heh, well I am being evil, looking for a fair bit more than that for Reyonso.

The problem for me selling is that he has pretty much the highest talent I have ever seen, and will have popped in DEF, PM and Pace within the next 2-3 weeks if my estimates of random pops are correct.

Anyway, I think that on Friday I will certainly be listing Springer. As for which other trainee to list, I think that may depend on if any of them random pop during the training update.

---

John Broadbent = 50k-100k i have seen players go for less with his skills
Joerg Brammer = 600-700k close to aging will damage him
Ingo Springer = 250k-300k to old
Hipólito Reynoso = 900k-1.1mill easily
(edited)

Its interesting how the valuations vary so wildly for the same players.

Shows how its all a matter of opinion really, it all depends on who wants to buy.