Subject: Valuations thread

That would do nicely!

but as you said - with good striker:) now they are worth less.

I know, but they'll have good striker soon enough, not too long to wait.

I'm in the market for a winger and would be interested to know what youse thought of someone like this:

Maurycy Animucki, age: 20
value: 222 000 €, wage: 2 375 €

formidable stamina, tragic keeper
solid pace, good defender
solid technique, solid playmaker
good passing, weak striker

Is that the sort of skills I should be looking? And what kind of a price would you say?

I'm training pace so plan to be upping that

I'd say he's more use as a central mid. If you're buying wingers you need high pace, passing and technique and playmaking is the lower priority. Buy strength in what you arent going to train.

Two players that dont quite fit my team, i am currently training pace with long team Striker focus. Any idea what should i do with these or what they would be worth? I dont think more pace training would be beneficial and when i switch to striker training, it wont benefit them....hmmmm
Buster Corscadden, age 19
value: 116 500 €, wage: 1 625 €
poor form
average stamina,
outstanding pace,
average technique,
average passing, hopeless keeper
solid defender
average playmaker
poor striker

Alex Quinn, age 21
value: 172 000 €, wage: 1 600 €
magical form
very good stamina,
very good pace,
excellent technique,
adequate passing, hopeless keeper
average defender
weak playmaker
poor striker

I would expect Corscadden to go for at least 500k, possibly a lot more. Quinn, not so much.

750k and i dont know... second of them is strange. 100k? thats max i think.

But don't they need the playmaking to be able to spot the best passes?

I think PM is more important than technique for true wingers. Most wingers will only ever get past a full back using pace rather than technique. Of course the optimum would be to have both :)

I have to disagree with you there. I've 4 wingers in my squad and the one least likely to get past defenders is the quickest because he doesn't have the technique of the others.

It depends on a lot of things really, most importantly positioning. I play my wingers higher up the pitch than yours so I look for different things. Nobody's right or wrong about these choices really, in the end different skills will give you different advantages. It's up to each manager to decide what kind of players they want to go with. A real life example would be Liverpool having Kyut on one side and Babel on the other. They're completely different players but you could say they're both equally effective (or ineffective ;) )

i also think thad nin have right here:) my vitturo have 17 on technique, and only 9 in PM. and he plays great.

what would these guys be worth?


thinking about keeping reidy for a spell of tech training tho,


Darren McMahon, age: 27
value: 321 000 €, wage: 3 225 €
club: Apoel Cormosia FC, country: Ireland
unearthly form, formidable tactical discipline
bookings:

formidable stamina, hopeless keeper
excellent pace, formidable defender
excellent technique, weak playmaker
poor passing, poor striker


Murray Reidy, age: 25
value: 298 500 €, wage: 3 150 €
club: Apoel Cormosia FC, country: Ireland
brilliant form, excellent tactical discipline
bookings:

formidable stamina, tragic keeper
formidable pace, formidable defender
adequate technique, unsatisfactory playmaker
solid passing, adequate striker

750k and 850k for me.

Because of the difference in technique 800k upwards for McMahon and 500k for Reidy