Subject: Season 10 Youths

Paste your youth squads for the next 16 weeks, not including today. It'd be helpful if i could have the complete list before we start pulls youths next Thursday.
There will be 2 months Plus for the best youth squad outside of the premiership. Dont try to cheat.

Niall Beirne excellent 1
Matthew Webb formidable 4
Patrick Carpenter solid 5
Adam Elce good 6
Damian Harris solid 6
Brett Bruins average 8
Jon Askin average 10
Phil O'Gara solid 14
Stuart Quinn adequate 15
(edited)

Jerry Carsley solid 4
Scott Tungate very good 5
Bill Moylan adequate 5
Scott Long average 6
Kaz Gray good 7
Brendan Bowdren very good 8
Thomas Dull solid 9
Colin Daish adequate 10
Flip May good 16
Rob Keenan adequate 16
Frank Kennedy adequate 17
Mick Lyons good 22
Chris Ducasse adequate 27

Kevin Dully excellent 1 Reject
Adrian Falvey solid 1 Reject
Corey Croom solid 5 Reject
Ian McGuinness very good 5 Reject
Robin Deans weak 9 Reject
Neil Deveraux good 10 Reject
James Keenan weak 10 Reject
Derek McIntyre excellent 10 Reject
Cormac Lee very good 13 Reject
Mike Aldidge average 15 Reject
Colin Keely average 15 Reject

Gordon Boylan very good 1
Nigel Zandstra good 3
Jim Saha good 5
Eoghan Clare good 5
Paddy Larkin adequate 5
Jim Eccles excellent 7
Justin Cullimore average 11
Brian Vadanan good 11
Cormac Grimes solid 14
Shane Connell solid 15

How are you choosing the best? The best 5 youths per squad or all of them added together?

To save arguments i'll be keeping the system private, unless Everest wins, in which case transparency is a better option.

Alex Griffin very good 1 Reject
Adrian Vadanan very good 1 Reject
Graham Farragher very good 7 Reject
Philip Davey good 7 Reject
Mike Roadknight average 8 Reject
Wayne Barter adequate 9 Reject
Bill Farragher very good 10 Reject
Nick Dale adequate 13 Reject
Paul Griffin very good 14 Reject
Shaun Haniotis average 15 Reject
Stuart Hogan average 19 Reject
Rob Harrington solid 24 Reject
Colin Clohessy adequate 27 Reject

Robert Mehrtens good 1
Alex May solid 1
Colm Keely adequate 1
Wayne Cascarino very good 2
Paddy Larkin very good 2
Cormac Cully outstanding 3
Paul Dearden good 6
Brett Focker adequate 7
Shane Day weak 8
Jamie Mooney adequate 10
Flip McDonald good 10
Robin Holmes very good 11
Frank Bok good 11
Jimmy Fennely good 12
Clayton Kumar solid 12

Dwayne De Khros solid 1
Damian Whittle adequate 1
Simon Lestina outstanding 1
James Sheridan good 5
Martin Palmer very good 12
Jimmy Ferry good 12
Scott Mok adequate 14
Jerry Armstrong good 15
Anthony Maher solid 15
Gerry Cole good 16

DISQULAIFIED!!! You are not allowed to try and subliminally influence Nin by bolding your best player lol.

Here's my little beauties:

Gareth Keely very good 1 Reject
Simon Grimes excellent 1 Reject
Jake Scanlon formidable 6 Reject
Greg McDonald good 7 Reject
Kaz Fleming excellent 8 Reject
Johnny Conner solid 8 Reject
Brent Hogan excellent 12 Reject
Luke Ballantine good 13 Reject
Peter Reilly adequate 13 Reject
(edited)

i only have 1 worth keeping, the rest are pure crud.

TBH even Simon's not that good!

Robin Sherlock excellent 3
Gerard Place very good 5
Jeff Clare very good 7
Trevor Ferriter very good 8
Murray Finnin very good 10
James Truman solid 11
Adam Dobbyn very good 13
Trevor Harte good 15

All coming out Excellent or above :)
(edited)

Ian Broing excellent 2
Sam Ampadu very good 3
Craig Hudson good 3
Colin Healy good 3
Peter Tungate very good 3
Scott Clery adequate 4
Rob McEneaney very good 4
Rick Keenan good 5
Jim Wilde solid 6
Andy Robinson solid 6
Andy Harris adequate 7
Dave Cryan formidable 7
Flip Malone very good 9
Gordon Denning very good 9
David Fanning adequate 10
Ray Fairley very good 10
Phil Mehrtens average 11

What week for Trevor Harte

15

Andrew Hulka very good 1
Simon Sullivan good 1
Jeff Creataro solid 3
Corey Cuffe excellent 4
Gordon Kealy solid 4
William Malhan very good 4
Brian Hoey excellent 5
Niall Fenlon excellent 6
James Morris excellent 6
Johan McEneaney solid 8
Danny Rickard adequate 9
Craig Lawrie solid 10
Nick Askin adequate 12
Flip Synnott good 12
Mike Elce weak 13
Patrick Knight good 13
Terry MacCowan adequate 14
Johnny Carthy adequate 14
Paddy Ainslie adequate 15
Trevor Place good 16


hmmm 20 players this year, much improved on last year! some decent ones in there too
(edited)
(edited)

Huge list, although i'm not sure why you've kept Jason Christian.