Subject: Season 21 Youths

Excellent must be ~30 sumskill with stamina. He had 26p - > in my opinion he is max medium very good.

Ed. Why x2 stamina? Weak = 4 points - it's all.
(edited)

it's well known that when u pull out a junior u want to have less stamina coz stamina affects more than the normal value itself ..in that case 4(weak)...same for gk.
so..if a junior is suposed to have total of skills 40 if he will have stamina and GK with level 1 the rest of his skils will have a total of 36..
if he will get good (7) stamina and 2 GK the total of the rest of his skills will be 22...kinda sucks
both have same level but those 2 (stamina +GK) affects more than others the total.
(edited)

if he will get good (7) stamina and 2 GK the total of the rest of his skills will be 22...kinda sucks

Exactly.

In Poland we did (even for the old rules in the young school) test on 50/60 juniors (in every level), and the results were exactly the same:

Adequate: ~18
Good: ~21
Solid: ~24
Very Good: ~27
Excellent: ~30
Formidable: ~34
Outstanding: ~38
Incredible: ~41
Brilliant: ~45
Magical: ~49

I doubt that after the changes in the YS there were any changes. Game developers are too lazy:P

I know the formula with total of skills(GK and stamina x 2) / 3.2
it works with all my juniors

got ripped off again.
from exellent talent around 3

Brendan Cregoe, age: 16, height: 193 cm
value: 54 000 €, wage: 875 €

poor stamina,
hopeless pace, good defender
hopeless technique, average playmaker
adequate passing, solid striker

from solid, talent unknown
William Stoker, age: 16, height: 177 cm
value: 29 000 €, wage: 625 €

poor stamina,
average pace, weak defender
poor technique, average playmaker
poor passing, hopeless striker

I know the formula with total of skills(GK and stamina x 2) / 3.2

or total skills / 3.0

it's not working sometimes this one

Are youse trying to say he wasn't formidable? I took a screen grab before pormoting hiom:

[URL=http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/684/sherlocksokker.jpg/][/URL]

Uploaded with ImageShack.us

35 total with my formula / 3,2 = 10.93...so..formidable indeed

In my formula excellent;) Select the same option that suits You:P

I do not deny that the DTD may be right. I presented my point of view + results from the Polish experience. Conclusions everyone has the same draw.

levels arent "accurate" since the new youth system with matches. theyre just estimates which are only accurate after the guy has played ~10 matches

as for the guys bickering its not stamina x 2 its like 1.6 or something.. dont remember the figure, but it definately does take a lot of points alright. its very annoying

either way its not important, hes not a great youth lol

Surely those kind of calculations are pointless cos the guy could be really high within each level or whatever? I mean it's not like every skill comes out at the mid-point or base point is it?

yeah thats true as such, but its a general guideline that usually is fairly accurate.
i mean those sum of points someone quoted (i have them in our newbie forum also) are also just points totalled which cud have had subskills also ;)