Subject: form & keepers

I've got an excellent keeper in tragic form & a solid keeper in magical... who would you play?

cheers!

Depends on their pace/passing too!

assuming all other stats were equal ;-)

go with the form guy

damn.. does form really span 2 skill levels? boo.....

thanks for the advice.

close at that level really - the excellent might be better

if form causes a percentage drop in ability then I would fully expect it to cause a 2 level drop on a divine, but I'm not so sure about an excellent I admit

Solid keeper for me. The form could effect passing as well (possibly pace??), so would go with form.

Its the same Vancian; and I base this directly on my experience with and excellent keepr (with passing poor,defending poor,technqiue poor, pace poor, playmaking poor) who was tragic form performed only 7%.

While my sub keeper on solid form performed 37%. His skill set is below:
Steven Arrow, age: 20
club: FC Jundullah, country: England
value: 71 550 £, wage: 915 £
solid form, hopeless tactical discipline

tragic stamina solid keeper
solid pace tragic defender
hopeless technique tragic playmaker
good passing hopeless striker

So I would say go with the solid guy for sure based directly on experience with the same problem.

Keeper ratings are misleading in matches where the opposition has very few attacks - their rating in these cases is a fraction of its potential; and in some cases they will not get a rating at all if they barely touch the ball. I haven't looked at the match here to see what the def % is, but be aware it may apply.

Just looked at the match. I think you right jim.

I see Jim. I did not know that. Thanks man.

by the match you meant my match?

Yep.

They only had 3 shots so didn't really trouble your keeper enough to give him a proper rating.

ahh I see.. Thanks Mr. Goat :D

cheers all!