Subject: Youths

also

Vinnie Woodyat, age: 19 -> Talent 5 weeks (Formidable)

this Stu Hanley guy is just way better.

up to you what u do as he's a lovely youngster, if it was me I'd sell him my 2 cents worth
(edited)

I see you've editted your post adding that 2nd paragraph.
As matt has already said, woodyat is complete crap compared to hanley.

If I still needed a striker trainee, I would buy him myself but I think he will sell for atleast 200k and I may be a lil conservative on that valuation.

Anyways, i've just put him in the ATT valuations thread in juniors transfers for you. Lets see what vilp thinks of him.

do you have a link to this forum, as I haven't found it

here you go

Junior Transfers (en)

copy and paste that into the search forum box :)

Alec Dawkins weak 26 Reject
Gerwin Breeze adequate 27 Reject
Geriant Pembridge average 28 Reject

All joined today and have decided to keep the lot!!

Ian Ricket unsatisfactory 2 Reject
Iestyn Clark good 4 Reject
Ryan Crump weak 7 Reject
Ceri Hodge adequate 14 Reject
Stu Rush unsatisfactory 22 Reject
Adam Noe poor 29 Reject

keeping clark, hodge and noe

I think he worth around or more than 1mil

I dont think he would go for that much. He'll be 19 in 6 or 7 weeks.
It is his talent that'll add the most value to him as his skills are nice but not exactly amazing.
(edited)

Well I will keep him and train him then, if he is only worth 200K, as it has cost me 1,2M to maintain the youth school for the last 2 seasons, with a Magical coach. He is the most talented player I've had, even better than Courteen & Todd, so hopefully in 2 or 3 seasons, I will have half the NT team on my books ;-)

Yarworth wasn't even that talented ( only 4 weeks) so I will sell some of my first team players to raise the cash.
(edited)

I gave that 200k as a low starting figure. Wait and see what vilpu says in the valuation thread before deciding whether to sell or not :)

Stu Hanley should be worth 4 000 000 $ - 6 000 000 $

thx :)

gotta say, I thought my estimate was on the lowest side though and coulda gone a fair bit higher with his talent with some interest in him :)

I can be wrong as well...Try to find a similar striker from the market and put him on your observation list.
That`s should help you out a bit I guess.

I'll stick my neck out here and say I reckon he'll go for more than that, but not where bbwelsh seems to think he'll go.


higher, lower, higer, lower

cant find anyone similar to him coming from a smallish country :P

I dont think your estimate is that far out though. I would say 333 334 $ to 583 334 $ depending on the amount of interest in the player.

Not trying to tell you that you're estimating wrong though as you do a damn good job doing all those estimates in the numerous valuation threads :)
I always like getting myself a 2nd opinion by you before I sell good juniors/players :)