Subject: u 2 chaglar?יש הבדל בין האימונים

...תראו, נניח ויש לי 3 שחקנים בני 17 זהים לחלוטין, כולם סוליד רמה פנימית 0 בה-כ-ל ולכולם גם יש כשרון חבוי תואם לגמרי
אחד אני מאמן הגנה, אחד קישור, ואחד התקפה, מי יעלה רמות הכי מהר? אני מאוד מקווה שאתם יודעים ושאני אוכל לקבל תשובה, אחרת המשחק הזה הולך להיות ממש קשה, עכשיו באנגלית לידידנו צ'אגלר
chaglar, this is for u :)
listen, if i have 3 17 yo's with the same skills, all solid on the lowest inner level and they all got the same hidden talent, 3 identical players.. till now all good? great :)
if i want to train one of them in def, the other in middle-field and the last one in the attack, whitch one will "get to the top" the fastest?
I'm hopin to get an answer especially from u ;)

I am not sure but i guess it will take a little bit faster for the striker then for the midfielders and the defenders.

but again i am not sure about it

Well, as I understand the question, if you have 3 definitely identical players for training and you will place them in def, mid and att; here are some situations;

* If you train stamina and pace, they will all take the same training.

* If you train pass, defense, playmaking, striker and technique, also choose "mid" in the training page, all of the mid will take more training and the others will take less.

* If you train pass, defense, playmaking, striker and technique, also choose "def" in the training page, the def player will take more training and the others will take less.

* If you train pass, defense playmaking, striker and technique, also choose "att" in the training page, the att player will take more training and the others will take less.

Hope I understood the question correctly. :)

ammmmmmm kinda
in general, i asked which training program takes the longest time to level up and which one the shortest..
u know hattrick, right? so mid=7 practices, att=6-7 practices and def=8 practices, all with solid trainer and 17 yo player.. so u can understand that it takes the strikers the shortest time to level up and the def the longest, thats what i asked, which practice is the quickest..
it is clear now, i hope :P
(edited)

Hmm, as I see in Sokker Turkiye forum, and my friends who give defense, playmaking, and striker, I can say that defense has the shortest time. (3-3,5 weeks) And then play making with about 3,5-4 weeks. Also striker training can reach 4 weeks; but, sometimes we can see 4,5 weeks.

Also I can't say that those are completely true. Moreover, skills of the trainer are also important.

but u can train 10 defenders, 10 midfielders or 6 strikers, am i right? so it doesn't make sence =/
and 3-4 weeks is pretty quick i think, i thought it would take something like 6 weeks min...
oh well, thanks for the answer, i guess im not gonna train attack after all :P

10 defenders, 10 midfielders or 6 strikers, am i right?

No, You can train 20 def, 20 mid and 12 att. By lining up different players and letting them play only 45 min. :) Then a subsitute enters the game. ;) However, they will all take a little bit training.

You are thinking about the training as it is in hattrick. But Sokker is a game which you can do what you want to. That is why I love Sokker. :)

and 3-4 weeks is pretty quick i think, i thought it would take something like 6 weeks min...

Well, you said the player is 17 y.o :)) And the training depends on not only age, but also hidden talent, as you know. ;)

and to pop up from trajic for hopeless will take much less time then to pop up from solid to very good :)

oh ok, now i think i got it, but 20 def/mis? how many players can take place as defenders in 1 game, 7? because i got only 3 substitute, no?
can i order one player in my tactic to play in the offensive line, but in the orders-squad i can put him as a defender? u know what i mean? because if so, then i can play with 10 def.. and train 10 players every single game, which means 20 every single week, or thats what u ment in the first place..
omg im so confused!! :P
(edited)

oh ok, now i think i got it, but 20 def/mis? how many players can take place as defenders in 1 game, 7? because i got only 3 substitute, no?
can i order one player in my tactic to play in the offensive line, but in the orders-squad i can put him as a defender? u know what i mean? because if so, then i can play with 10 def.. and train 10 players every single game, which means 20 every single week, or thats what u ment in the first place..
omg im so confused!! :P

lol :) You are right. Sorry for that :)) Yes, there can be only 3 substitute and 5 def/mid. So, you can train 8 player in a match. And for a week, you can train 16 different players. not 20 :))

Hope it is clear now :)

I forgot that only 3 substitute can enter the game. That is why I wrote 20. Sorry.

of course it is =) thank u very much..